Comment by iowemoretohim

Comment by iowemoretohim 13 hours ago

14 replies

Why is leaking the video the right thing? There were multiple videos of the incident including footage from a EarthCam live camera. And the NTSB released multiple videos as part of their investigation. The video wasn't leaked in order to stop a coverup.

s_dev 12 hours ago

>Why is leaking the video the right thing?

Because it's in the public interest. The law doesn't state what's right only what's permitted.

ajross 12 hours ago

Isn't that an even stronger argument that the leak shouldn't be criminal?

  • JumpCrisscross 12 hours ago

    No, for the same that stealing an item isn’t okay because there is more in the back.

    • ajross 11 hours ago

      Impact and harm is absolutely part of the criteria by which we judge crimes and penalties. Not sure where you're going with that.

      • JumpCrisscross 9 hours ago

        Of course harm matters. Stealing a priceless original is worse, and punished harder, than stealing a commodity out of a corner store. That doesn’t mean the latter is fine.

    • userbinator 12 hours ago

      You can infinitely "steal" digital data. That's where the analogy breaks down.

      Imaginary property is imaginary.

      • JumpCrisscross 12 hours ago

        > Imaginary property is imaginary

        Property, a social construct, is always imaginary. The ship on IP, from insider trading laws to copyright, has sailed. If the only argument against a potential crime is IP isn’t real, the person is probably wrong.