Comment by bluenose69

Comment by bluenose69 2 days ago

42 replies

As has been noted by others, the emoting is a distraction. I could only watch this for a few seconds.

Another thing: why are they reporting speed in miles per hour, and altitude in feet? Surely anybody interested in space is familiar with SI units.

Tankenstein 2 days ago

Just a guess, but aerospace generally works with feet for altitude and knots/mph for airspeed, internationally. I’m doing a PPL in Europe and we, like everybody, use feet and knots/mph. I believe this is because the US have been on the forefront of aerospace regulation (a set of rules called the chicago convention is the basis of all air law) and aircraft manufacturing.

  • raverbashing 2 days ago

    Not for aerospace no

    And knots are not mph, they're "nautical miles per hour" which are a different measure (1nm is 1.8km, not 1.6km as the regular mile")

    • Tankenstein 2 days ago

      Sorry, not a native speaker, I was under the impression that aerospace means air and space. I guess i meant aviation.

      I didn’t imply knots are mph, I used the slash to signify “or”. They are completely different units, but both are used. Sometimes the airspeed indicator even has two scales, one for kt and one for mph.

  • throw5959 2 days ago

    Can confirm, all aviation worldwide deals in feet and knots. It's also because it's much easier to do calculations on the fly (literally) - in your head. Metric is precise and logical but harder to use in stressful situations.

    • curl-up 2 days ago

      Can you please give some real-world example of why it's easier to do calculations? Not disputing what you say, just hard for me to imagine why it would be so.

      • HPsquared 2 days ago

        1 knot is about 100 ft/min which is very convenient for descent at a specific glide slope (i.e. for 100 knots ground speed at 5% slope you want 500 ft/min descent rate). Standard is 3° which is about 5%.

        Knots are also handy for navigation as 1 nautical mile equals 1 minute of latitude. And of course a knot is 1 nautical mile per hour. So if you're doing 300 knots, that's 5 degrees of latitude per hour.

        The units fit together nicely as a system.

    • plantain 2 days ago

      Certainly not "worldwide". China uses metres. Recreational aircraft in Europe often use metres (almost all sailplanes).

      • throw5959 2 days ago

        No glider I have ever stepped in used metres. It doesn't make any sense, the tower wants to hear feet and knots and will communicate using that.

      • Tankenstein 2 days ago

        Thank you, I wasn't aware of China using metres. It turns out Russia uses them as well, confusingly below the transition level.

    • lupusreal 2 days ago

      You can be just as precise with either system.

    • inglor_cz 2 days ago

      "Metric is precise and logical but harder to use in stressful situations."

      That fully depends on your cultural background. Feet, miles etc. are so foreign to me that I would be unable to calculate with them under stress.

      But I am not a pilot nor a navigator, so...

      • throw5959 2 days ago

        No, it doesn't. I'm European, never used imperial before I became a pilot, and it's easier. Check it out, the formulas are much simpler to do in your head. Intuition doesn't matter, all that matters is that I can do the calculations quickly so I know I'm within parameter limits.

MattPalmer1086 2 days ago

Glad to hear it wasn't just me being grumpy, I also found it immensely annoying and distracting.

bigstrat2003 2 days ago

Who cares what units they use? Anyone who is interested in space will have some knowledge of both kinds of units, and can do conversions if they need to.

rqtwteye 2 days ago

Definitely should be football fields or school buses to make it comprehensible for the average viewer. Or “2 times the speed of a bullet”

justin66 2 days ago

> Another thing: why are they reporting speed in miles per hour, and altitude in feet? Surely anybody interested in space is familiar with SI units.

The audience that matters most to them is Americans, and they're happy to accommodate even those who are less interested in space.

Tepix 2 days ago

Perhaps it's considered more patriotic to reject scientific units?

I don't understand why they reserve 6 digits for the speed in mph either. Are they expecting it to go beyond 99,999 mph?

  • justlikereddit 2 days ago

    Do they also report the speed of light as Walmart parking lots per standard commercial tv break duration?

    Edit: as an Amazon product it would probably use Amazon(tm) cardboard box unit as the length metric and standardized warehouse drone toilet break as duration.

    • Dalewyn 2 days ago

      You're trying to break free of Earth's gravity well, so you might as well use Freedom Units.

      • justlikereddit 2 days ago

        Do you count them as Freedoms per second or is time included in a Freedom?