Comment by GuinansEyebrows

Comment by GuinansEyebrows 16 hours ago

22 replies

maybe this is a cheap comment but i truly cannot see the value in a home video security system - the cost of which is probably comparable to a decent home insurance policy with theft coverage. i don't even want cameras in my home that i have full control over, let alone internet-connected cameras that can be viewed by third parties (authorized or not)... and i'm boring at home. anything i own of sentimental value has little to no monetary value, and the latter category is all things that can be replaced.

what value do these systems actually provide to anyone but the manufacturers and those capable of exploiting them?

lurking_swe 15 hours ago

useful if:

- you are in a high crime area. footage can be useful to police.

- you have a babysitter or nanny for a young child, and want to deter unethical / wrongful behavior.

- you have a pet that you leave at home for parts of the day, and want to keep an eye on them. to “check in” while on the go.

- you have an elderly family member and don’t live nearby, and want to be able to quickly see if they’ve fallen. for example if they call you daily and suddenly aren’t answering their phone. Good peace of mind.

- pointing a camera at the stovetop can be useful to solve the age old question “did i forget to turn the stove off?”

- pointing a camera out the window to see something fun. For example birds, deer, squirrels, etc.

That’s just what i could think of in 2 minutes. I’m sure there are other use cases.

  • iszomer 28 minutes ago

    Outside: porch pirates and the occasional sneaky meth head; inside: basement boiler amperage and fuel capacity readouts.

  • GuinansEyebrows 15 hours ago

    i think practically all of these hypotheticals can be addressed without signing over your in-home privacy to a third party who doesn't consider IT security a top priority though.

    • lurking_swe 13 hours ago

      I hear you. But for a normal consumer who’s afraid of technology? Doubt it.

      As a nerd I can easily set up some webcams on my wifi, place them on a firewalled IOT vlan, and securely expose them through the ios home app (with HomeAssistant)…and call it a day.

      But your average person has no clue how to do that, or anything similar…nor do they care. Sad but true.

throwawaylaptop 15 hours ago

I have two friends that installed them to basically deter their wives from cheating at their house when they are away. You could argue it's to 'catch' but obviously they aren't even going to attempt it knowing the cameras are present.

  • abujazar 14 hours ago

    That's quite abusive behavior. I'm sorry for these wives, having to deal with this as it's probably not the only thing they have to endure. And how do the spouses "prove" they're not cheating when they're away - or is that not so important because they can choose to do whatever?

    • worthless-trash 11 hours ago

      Can we stop labeling anything that makes someone 'unhappy' as abusive. Its not and i'm tired of pretending it is.

      • k1t 9 hours ago

        Installing cameras to control/monitor your spouse is definitely abusive behavior.

  • toofy 12 hours ago

    partner installing cameras to try and catch them cheating? that’s creepy af, no wonder they’re cheating.

    if they can’t leave their creepy partner for some reason, hopefully they look up how to bypass security cameras in an obvious way just to annoy the creepy guy.

  • pxc 12 hours ago

    If the wives want to cheat, won't they then just do it somewhere else? Or is that actually the point, they just don't want their memories of the house tainted, or to be traumatized by coming home to it?

  • hulitu 4 hours ago

    > I have two friends that installed them to basically deter their wives from cheating at their house when they are away.

    In some coutries, this will land them in jail.

  • GuinansEyebrows 15 hours ago

    i feel like there are a lot of things i could say but i'll leave it at "woof"

    • throwawaylaptop 14 hours ago

      In regards to how often people cheat in marriage (the stats are a bit sad), or of someone using cameras to deter it from happening?

      • amanaplanacanal 14 hours ago

        By the time you decide to install cameras to deter your partner from cheating, your relationship is already way beyond fucked.

      • GuinansEyebrows 14 hours ago

        yes, and more! but my feelings on the situations you've described are off topic :)

  • [removed] 15 hours ago
    [deleted]
lazyeye 7 hours ago

The solution is to block the camera’s mac address at the router and then access them remotely via Tailscale.