Show HN: I made a Doom-like game fit inside a QR code

(github.com)

525 points by kuberwastaken 5 days ago

142 comments

View on Hacker News

I sometimes pick up random projects just because I can, this was one of those times. I made it as a week long project a while back this year but never shared here, so thought to go for it haha.

I created a game inspired by Doom and the backrooms called The Backdooms under 2.4kb in minified html. (for reference, this entire post would be around 1.8kB haha) I had to use a not popular way of using GZip with Zlib headers (had to write my own script for compressing it, also in the repo) to eventually convert it a size 40 QR code that works right in your browser using Decompressionstream API.

This is of course a very oversimplified description of it, using a lot of the same technologies that DOOM had but combining it with infinite seed based map generation in 2.4kb (QR codes can only store 3kb, which includes changing formats) was pretty hard.

Here are some links about it if you want to nerd out and read more:

Repository Link (MIT License): https://github.com/Kuberwastaken/backdooms

A Hosted (slightly improved) version of The Backdooms: https://kuberwastaken.github.io/backdooms/

Game Trailer: https://www.youtube.com/shorts/QWPr10cAuGc

My Linkedin post about it: https://www.linkedin.com/feed/update/urn:li:activity:7295667...

(PS: You'd need something like https://qrscanner.org/ or something that can scan bigger QR codes and put the text data onto your browser to play it)

My Blogs documenting the process and development in detail:

https://kuberwastaken.github.io/blog/Projects/How-I-Managed-... https://kuberwastaken.github.io/blog/Projects/How-I-Managed-...

sangeeth96 5 days ago

TIL DecompressionStream, thanks. I managed to shave some more bytes by trimming the HTML bits, raised a PR in case you're interested.

Reply View 4 replies
  • kuberwastaken 5 days ago

    YOU'RE A LEGEND! I just managed to ADD (somewhat of) TOUCHSCREEN SUPPORT, better movement, enemy spawning and damage mechanisms in the space that freed up because of this! Genuinely, thank you, made my month :)

    Reply View 3 replies
redbell 5 days ago

Really cool project! TIL about 'data:' URLs—while I was familiar with the 'data:' URI scheme and had used it before, I didn’t realize it could be used as a full URL. Funny enough, I had been thinking about building something similar that fits entirely within a QR code, but I held off because I mistakenly thought it would require an HTTP(s) link. I was heavily inspired by this work: Can you fit a whole game into a QR code?(https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ExwqNreocpg)

Reply View 1 reply
  • kuberwastaken 5 days ago

    Thank you for your kind words! I was also inspired by this video back in lockdown, I believe, super cool but I went the opposite route for browser based because of more compatibility.

    I have them credited in the repo as well :P

    Reply View 0 replies
cosignal 5 days ago

Pardon my dumb query, as I'm a tech novice, but aren't QR just encodings of data? And the max amount of data a QR can encode is like 3kb, which would roughly correspond to 3000 or so plaintext characters. So the achievement here is that this Doom-like game can be run from an executable roughly of that size?

Reply View 1 reply
  • matheusmoreira 5 days ago

    QR codes have various encoding modes: numeric, alphanumeric, 8 bit and kanji. The most common is alphanumeric encoding and the densest is 8 bit encoding which just stores binary data.

    The QR code standards seem to be a little ambiguous on the meaning and purpose of the 8 bit encoding. I got the impression they added it to support alternative character encodings. Still, it's a mode that "represents an 8-bit byte value directly".

    > The default interpretation for QR Code is ECI 000020 representing the JIS8 and Shift JIS character sets.

    > 8.3.4 8-bit Byte Mode

    > The 8-bit byte mode handles the 8-bit Latin/Kana character set in accordance with JIS X 0201 (character values 00HEX to FFHEX).

    > In this mode data is encoded at a density of 8 bits/character.

    > 8.4.4 8-bit Byte Mode

    > In this mode, one 8 bit codeword directly represents the JIS8 character value of the input data character as shown in Table 6, i.e. a density of 8 bits/character.

    > In ECIs other than the default ECI, it represents an 8-bit byte value directly.

    In any case, it is possible to use QR codes to store arbitrary binary data. The qrencode tool can do this natively. Decoder support is more tricky, they tend to assume all QR codes contain text. I had to send patches to zbar to help it decode QR codes with binary data in them because it was passing the data through iconv and mangling the output. I also had to add options to the zbar tools to make them decode exactly one QR code

    I just wanted to print out 4096 bit RSA secret keys as QR codes. People started QR encoding video games pretty soon after. It's awesome.

    https://youtu.be/ExwqNreocpg

    https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24287347

    Reply View 0 replies
giarc 5 days ago

I scanned on an iPhone using native QR code scanner and it says "no usable data found".

Reply View 33 replies
  • pudquick 5 days ago

    data: URI URLs aren't supported in it, it has nothing to do with the size / length of the QR code

    For example, this self-contained webpage: <html><body>Hi!</body></html>

    encoded is: data:text/html;base64,PGh0bWw+PGJvZHk+SGkhPC9ib2R5PjwvaHRtbD4=

    If you paste that into a browser, it will render "Hi!". Very short and easy.

    But if you encode is as a QR code, it won't work in this situation.

    Reply View 9 replies
    • myfonj 5 days ago

      You don't even need the base64 encoding for dataURIs: just throw the text payload after mime-type and a comma:

          data:text/html,<!doctype html><title>Hi!</title><p>Hello.
      This is also a valid self-contained HTML document. You have to add `;charset=utf-8`, if you need to go beyond ASCII, and for some browsers watch for URI-encoding of some syntactically significant characters (like `#` and `%`, `?`).

      Base64 is indeed good to be "safe" and/or somewhat 'conceal' the payload, but it also makes it larger by 1/3 (every three bytes of input become four characters of the base64 output). So taking the risk some devices would not like raw "ASCII dataURI", the QR of the backrooms QR could shave off 738 bytes.

      BTW, this is my "HTML sandbox" for testing stuff in a browsers that I summon daily through keyword bookmark to test simple stuff:

          data:text/html;charset=utf-8;verbatim,<!doctype html><html style="color-scheme:dark light"><title>HTML sandbox 2.0.6</title><meta name=viewport content=width=device-width,initial-scale=1><body style=margin:0;display:flex;height:100vh onload="OT=(DC=document).title,H=(L=location).hash.slice(1)||'',RX=/(^data:.+?(;verbatim)?,)?([^]*)/,A.value=H.match(RX)[2]?H:decodeURIComponent(H)||A.value;T=W=0;E=RegExp('^'+(D='data:text/html;charset=utf-8,'));F=()=>{if(W!=(V=A.value))W=V,M=V.match(RX),I.src=M[2]?V:(M[1]||D)+encodeURIComponent(M[3]),DC.title=NT=((TM=V.match(/<title\b[^]*?\x3E([^]*?)<\/title\b/m))&&(NT=TM[1])&&(NT=NT.trim())&&(DC.title=NT+' @ '+OT))||OT};F()"><textarea autocapitalize=off style=resize:horizontal;width:50vw autofocus id=A onkeyup=clearTimeout(T);T=setTimeout(F,400) onblur=try{history.pushState({},NT,'\u0023'+(S=I.src.replace(E,'')))}catch(e){L.hash=S}><!doctype html><html lang="en" style="color-scheme: dark light;">%0A<meta name="viewport" content="width=device-width, initial-scale=1">%0A<title>%0A%0A</title>%0A<style>%0A%0A</style>%0A<body>%0A%s%0A<script>%0A%0A</script>%0A</textarea><iframe style=border:0;flex-grow:1;width:0 id=I>
      Reply View 5 replies
      • reaperducer 5 days ago

        I think I'm going to find this useful.

        Duck browser doesn't allow it to be saved as a bookmark, but Safari is fine with it.

        Reply View 3 replies
      • [removed] 4 days ago
        [deleted]
        Reply View 0 replies
    • kuberwastaken 5 days ago

      I think it's broken for safari but works on chromium based browsers on mobile too. The QR code basically holds the URI URL itself.

      Reply View 2 replies
      • pudquick 5 days ago

        I'm saying the primary gateway most iOS users are using for loading a QR code - the camera app - will not present a transition to load your URL in this situation

        Whether the resulting HTML game is playable in Safari is a different discussion.

        The QR code, as generated, is effectively "not clickable" for most iOS users, unless they are using something other than the most common way to read QR codes on their phone like a 3rd party QR code reading app or similar.

        Reply View 1 reply
  • kuberwastaken 5 days ago

    Hey thanks for checking it out! You'd need something like https://qrscanner.org/ because most phones suck at scanning larger QR codes.

    Also, it won't work on your phone, can't put in that compatibility with size restraints, sadly.

    Reply View 10 replies
    • ascorbic 5 days ago

      fwiw, it works fine with the Pixel's built-in QR code scanner. It recognises it as text, not a URL, but it can copy to clipboard and then pasting in the browser works. Obviously I then die immediately because none of the controls work, but you can't have everything.

      Reply View 1 reply
      • kuberwastaken 5 days ago

        Hey just wanted to update, crazy timing but I Managed to add kind of some mobile touch support here because of a recent PR to FURTHER optimize it (crazy), so you can actually play it now if you figure out the controls lol

        Reply View 0 replies
    • iainmerrick 5 days ago

      You mean the game doesn't work on mobile at all?

      What kind of device do you use to scan the QR code, then?

      Reply View 7 replies
      • lelandbatey 5 days ago

        You do not need to scan a QR code via a physical camera in your hand directly; any general purpose computer can run a QR code parsing program which accepts arbitrary images as input. It's so easy to do that there exist web pages which implement said QR code scanning in JS. Thus, the parent poster has recommended that you save the QR code .png file to your disk and then use such a piece of software, such as the website they linked, to extract the data encoded in that QR code.

        That is how you can use nearly any general-purpose computer to scan a QR code.

        Reply View 3 replies
      • kuberwastaken 5 days ago

        Hey just wanted to update, I Managed to add kind of some mobile touch support here, so if you get an alternate chromium based browser, you can put in the URI to play on mobile too!

        Reply View 1 reply
      • kuberwastaken 5 days ago

        Nope it doesn't, you can use any QR code scanner that takes image input! I would've loved to include smartphone controls but that would take a LOT of extra bandwidth.

        Reply View 0 replies
  • Jerry2 5 days ago

    I'm kinda relieved that it doesn't work on an iPhone. I often scan codes posted around to save the time typing URLs and running arbitrary code by just scanning a QR code freaks me out.

    Reply View 11 replies
    • kuberwastaken 5 days ago

      Ironically, I actually wrote a blog about how casually we do this and how dangerous it's become lol https://kuberwastaken.github.io/blog/Technology/QR-Codes-and...

      Reply View 4 replies
      • Valodim 4 days ago

        The content is good, but fyi the last third or so had a distinct ai padding vibe

        Reply View 2 replies
      • [removed] 5 days ago
        [deleted]
        Reply View 0 replies
    • Blikkentrekker 5 days ago

      It runs inside a web browser though. This is no different from visiting an arbitrary link and running whatever arbitrary code in the Javascript sandbox of that link and one already knows a q.r. code an take one to an arbitrary link.

      Reply View 3 replies
      • Blikkentrekker 4 days ago

        That said, I wouldn't mind an upgrade to the standard of say say if the link be printed above the code in human readable form in some way, the reader would refuse to open it, or at least be configurable to refuse to open it if they not match.

        Reply View 0 replies
      • dylan604 5 days ago

        This QR code does. But what about a QR using similar designed by someone less honorable? With QR codes, you have no idea what will happen until you scan it. At that point, it could be too late

        Reply View 1 reply
        • Blikkentrekker 4 days ago

          As far as I know the only form of code execution they support is by the URL datatype which carries the same risks as wel already mentioned anyway.

          Reply View 0 replies
    • berkes 4 days ago

      How is this different from opening any website through a QR code, that will then run "arbitrary code"?

      Reply View 0 replies
    • recursive 5 days ago

      Wait until you hear about javascript on web sites.

      Reply View 0 replies
jasonjmcghee 5 days ago

You should update the css for the canvas to be `image-rendering: pixelated` so things look crisp rather than blurry!

Reply View 1 reply
r1chardnl 5 days ago

Your game trailer links to a short called "Fly me to the moon - 19 September 2024". I think this is a mistake?

Reply View 2 replies
kamranjon 4 days ago

A friend and I were talking about a somewhat related idea.

We were wondering if we could encode the STL for a 3d print entirely into a QR code and then put that on the actual printed object - so that any piece you made could be replicated by just scanning the object and printing again.

When looking into it I thought it just was too much data, even looked into multi-colored QR codes. But I didn’t realize you could just make a bigger QR code…

Reply View 1 reply
  • jkestner 3 days ago

    Did this a while ago for a table as a design exploration. We encoded a 2D file (because the table only required cutting sheet materials) and still had to use a custom compression algorithm for the proof of concept. https://johnkestner.com/rev/

    Reply View 0 replies
teleforce 5 days ago

In the last Def Con 32 the badge can run full Doom on Pico 2 [1].

[1] Running Doom on the Raspberry Pi Pico 2: A Def Con 32 Badge Hack:

https://shop.sb-components.co.uk/blogs/posts/running-doom-on...

Reply View 3 replies
  • kuberwastaken 4 days ago

    Yup, Raspberry Pi could always run it haha, good compute on it.

    Reply View 2 replies
    • opan 4 days ago

      The Pico is a microcontroller, like an arduino, in case you didn't know. Doesn't run a full GNU/Linux. Not to be confused with the Nano.

      Reply View 1 reply
below43 4 days ago

This is very cool. On a similar bent I built https://urlfile.app because I wanted to see if I could share files via a URL (and I also wanted to genrate QR codes via Edge so I could load the files onto my phome). It works for small files fairly well...

Reply View 1 reply
metalman 5 days ago

I am now waiting for news that someone has bio hacked a cockroach or a fruitfly to play doom, if not autonomously then for the full cold shivers, they are now robotisising insects, which could then be accesed through an interface to play doom on a toothbrush booted from a qr code. Sci-fi is lagging

Reply View 1 reply
redeyedtreefrog 4 days ago

Pretty cool, though like others I had some slight technical issues. On Firefox mobile I got a black screen (that was yesterday, maybe it's been updated since then). Firefox desktop today it worked once I figured out that:

a) the keyboard doesn't work until after I click to fire, and this state resets itself every time I press f5 to restart the game (presumably a browser focus issue)

b) both up/down and w/s work for back and forward, but a and d don't work for left and right, you need to use the left/right arrows.

The combination of the two had me scratching my head for a little while!

Reply View 1 reply
  • kuberwastaken 4 days ago

    Heyo! Thanks for checking it out! "On Firefox mobile I got a black screen" - Yup I broke it while trying to add mobile controls earlier, but it works well now!

    "the keyboard doesn't work until after I click to fire, and this state resets itself every time I press f5 to restart the game" yes- this is actually something for starting the game music and some other processes

    Reply View 0 replies
sebastiennight 4 days ago

Tested it on an offline Android. I'm amazed that it works, although I could never figure out the controls so I always end up dead within a few seconds!

You might want to explain those controls in the readme :)

Reply View 1 reply
  • kuberwastaken 4 days ago

    Yes, it takes a while to get used to but it somewhat works lol

    I'll try to familiarize myself with it more and add it eventually!

    Reply View 0 replies
Bengalilol 5 days ago

Great crazy thing! I am waiting for the addition of "self contained QR code" to canitrundoom (although I don't know if it can be technically approved).

Yet... that game will now make me think twice before scanning any QR ^^

Reply View 1 reply
deadbabe 5 days ago

How can there not be even one screenshot of the game in the readme?

Reply View 7 replies
  • kuberwastaken 5 days ago

    Because it kept evolving and it was more related to the development than the game itself.

    But if you want to skip the friction of scanning the QR code, you can directly play a hosted version at: https://kuberwastaken.github.io/backdooms/

    Reply View 4 replies
    • deadbabe 5 days ago

      It doesn’t work, but I don’t really care to play I just want to see the screenshots of what you made.

      Reply View 0 replies
    • ant6n 5 days ago

      Doesnt work on iOS (ipad). A screenshot would be nice.

      Reply View 2 replies
      • kuberwastaken 5 days ago

        Hey just wanted to update, I Managed to add kind of some mobile touch support here, so if you get an alternate chromium based browser, you can put in the URI to play on mobile too!

        Reply View 0 replies
frellus 5 days ago

This stuff is starting to feel closer to Snow Crash than I'm comfortable with, when I saw that QR code I wondered if my brain was being altered :-D Amazing work.

Reply View 1 reply
eastoeast 4 days ago

This is super cool. Recently, I tried making an offline, P2P chat program that fits inside of a QR code. In case network was down, the code could be scanned by mobile, allowing users to join a chat room. However this doesn’t seem possible at the moment, as 1. browsers don’t allow offline direct communication for safety reasons 2. couldn’t fit all needed data/prereq modules within the QR.

Reply View 0 replies
bananaboy 5 days ago

Very cool! Minor nitpick though: DOOM didn’t use raycasting. This is really a Wolfenstein 3D-like, since Wolf3D did use ray casting.

Reply View 6 replies
  • Narishma 4 days ago

    Given the lack of textured walls, it's more like a Hovertank 3D-like.

    Reply View 2 replies
    • bananaboy 4 days ago

      Absolutely! I figured people are more familiar with wolf3d though.

      Reply View 0 replies
    • kuberwastaken 3 days ago

      I mean- I wanted textures but that's borderline impossible with the size

      Reply View 0 replies
  • Max-q 4 days ago

    This is the obligatory comment on every ray casting game calling itself Doom like. I was scrolling down the page, checking if I had to add it, but luckily it was already done :-D

    Reply View 1 reply
    • bananaboy 4 days ago

      I have been doing the same since the 90s reading people on usenet calling DOOM raycasting hahaha

      Reply View 0 replies
  • kuberwastaken 4 days ago

    I KNOW haha! I wanted to include the backrooms concept with the infinite map and such and Wolfenstein 3D seemed fitting for the theme haha

    Reply View 0 replies
kuberwastaken 5 days ago

Update: Managed to add kind of some mobile touch support (literally insane) because of a PR by @sangeeth96 on the repo

Reply View 0 replies
Mainan_Tagonist 5 days ago

After several tries, i managed to play it, sort of, on Brave on my Samsung S9.

Very impressive compression trick, as a proof of concept, it is worthy of praise, congrats.

I imagine this approach could be used for much more practical uses.

Reply View 5 replies
  • kuberwastaken 5 days ago

    Thank you so much haha and yes! It indeed can, I always also like the idea of having QR code game cartridges of sorts haha

    (PS I updated the hosted version again and it's much better for mobile controls, try it out if you get the time!)

    Reply View 2 replies
    • Mainan_Tagonist 4 days ago

      I was thinking yesterday whether it would have a potential application in the field of low resources communication : you produce a QR code containing your info that you transmit over SSTV so the other party can get the message. Supposedly much more efficient than FT8 or JS8Call.

      Reply View 1 reply
  • dylan604 5 days ago

    Or much more malevolent as well. Just because something novel and fun/entertaining can be done does not mean assholes will not use the same techniques for their gain.

    PoCs like this are neat and definitely shows some skillz by the author, but now I'm hoping security types take a look at this to see how vulnerable this could be from asshats.

    Reply View 1 reply
    • autoexec 5 days ago

      It's already a good practice not to go around scanning random QR codes. Nobody has to go through the trouble of compressing a bunch of code to run in your browser when you can just make a QR code point to any malicious domain on the internet and infect devices all day long.

      Reply View 0 replies
askvictor 5 days ago

Firefox mobile on Android gives "Cannot complete request; Additional information about this problem or error is currently unavailable" :(

Reply View 1 reply
Lerc 5 days ago

I don't want to take away from the achievement because it really is awesome, and should be celebrated.

...but...

It seems like a fundamental design issue to make a QR code game that isn't designed for the platform where QR codes are most used.

Reply View 3 replies
  • kuberwastaken 5 days ago

    Hey just wanted to update, I Managed to add kind of some mobile touch support here thanks to an awesome PR to further reduce the size, so if you get a chromium based browser, you can put in the URI to play on mobile too!

    Reply View 0 replies
  • kuberwastaken 5 days ago

    Totally understandable, I can make a snake game inside it fully compatible with mobile but mobile controls just take up a lot of space due to the sheer nature of them haha.

    But the compression algorithm is up, feel free to make what you think is awesome and compatible, I'd love to see if you find out hacky solutions to make that work too :P

    Reply View 1 reply
    • Lerc 5 days ago

      I might just do something like that. Although I inevitably get caught up in designing some minor tech part.

      Last time I attempted something like that I made stack machine texture maker, then embedded it inside a version of TTT that minifies+gzips to under 1500bytes. After a few years of pondering I think there are a few more enhancements to be had.

      For reference, This URL has a bunch of textures in it.

      https://fingswotidun.com/ttt/#W1s2NCw2NCwxMzExOV0sWzY0LDY0LD...

      Reply View 0 replies
kazinator 4 days ago

If that QR code itself appeared as a texture on a wall inside the game, I would shit my pants.

Reply View 0 replies
[removed] 5 days ago
[deleted]
Reply View 0 replies
jerjerjer 5 days ago

Year 3567: automatic interstellar probe finds remnants a technical alien civilization.

Year 3678, Show HN: I compiled DOOM for an alien CPU architecture.

Vernor Vinge kind of touches this topic a bit in his Zones of Thought series.

Reply View 7 replies
smusamashah 5 days ago

Please add a few screenshots to the repo. I am on phone and for whatever reason all I could see was 3 buttons and black screen.

Edit: Add a gif instead, you won't have to rely on YouTube with that.

Reply View 6 replies
  • kuberwastaken 5 days ago

    Alright! First thing tomorrow :)

    Also pushed a commit to hopefully fix the blank screen issue for phones!

    Reply View 3 replies
    • xandrius 5 days ago

      Still black screen on Firefox mobile.

      Reply View 2 replies
      • kuberwastaken 5 days ago

        Sorry, should be completely fixed now, with a neat little joystick (I presume you're speaking of the hosted verison)

        Reply View 0 replies
      • notnmeyer 5 days ago

        ios? same thing on safari, and probably every ios browser

        Reply View 0 replies
  • [removed] 4 days ago
    [deleted]
    Reply View 0 replies
the_arun 5 days ago

My iPhone camera says - "No Usable Data found" when I scan the QR code.

On a different context, loading a game in QR code also made me to think, can anyone inject a malware script using QR codes?

Reply View 6 replies