Comment by cratermoon

Comment by cratermoon 3 months ago

10 replies

The headline is somewhat begging the question, but the author's key observation is on point: People homeschooling their kids are implicitly, and sometimes explicitly, going for "opt out of being around average people".

ARandomerDude 3 months ago

Increasing the quantity and quality of good influences on your children is just good parenting.

If I know there's a kid down the street who seems like he will grow up to be a criminal, and another kid who seems like he'll grow up to be a kind, hard-working, well adjusted person, there is a 100% guarantee I will encourage my kids to play with the second kid, not the first.

  • nineplay 3 months ago

    The poster above references the 'average person'. Do you think that the average person is not going to be a good influence?

    • theamk 3 months ago

      Average person _where_?

      If the school is bad enough, then an average student there (because there are many more students than teachers) might not be a good influence.

      There are schools in my state with <50% graduation rate, the average student there won't even finish the school.

      • cratermoon 3 months ago

        So ability to graduate from high school determines the worth of a person?

        • theamk 3 months ago

          I am not saying anything about "worth of a person", I don't believe it is even a thing.

          All I know that children (and many adults too) do similar thing that their peers do. So if I want to increase the chance that my child will graduate from high school, they should be around people who will graduate from high school. Similarly, if no one in their class will go to college, the chances they will go to college will be smaller.

          Note there are exception to the each rule, and I am talking about "chances", not certainties.

    • [removed] 3 months ago
      [deleted]
dingnuts 3 months ago

I found this explanation extremely unsatisfying considering that you could make the same choice and put your child into private education if you're a successful tech person.

I know families that homeschool and I like to read articles like this one to see if anyone "gets it." So far, no hits.

They're opting out of mediocre instruction and government-mandated values enforcement ("DEI" in its public school curricula form); the other kids are irrelevant. The homeschoolers I know are average and have lots of social activities with average peers in their community.

  • cratermoon 3 months ago

    If you look around and see "government-mandated values enforcement ("DEI" in its public school curricula form)", I already fear for your children, whether you home school them or not.

    • superq 3 months ago

      You fear for other people's kids.. over politics?