Comment by UniverseHacker
Comment by UniverseHacker 17 hours ago
This is the same argument the authors make to reviewer #3:
"At this moment, we think that the thermal energy can be supplied to the devices from the surrounding air which possesses thermal energy such as 25 meV at room temperature. The air surrounding the devices can be considered as an infinite heat bath, and the analogized conditions of steady light irradiation in a solar cell, i.e., “photon absorption,” are considered to be formed by “phonon absorption.”"
This sounds like nonsense to me- I don't think a solar cell would function without a gradient either, e.g. if the cell itself were the same temperature as the light source.
Does a photon carry information about the temperature of it's source?
What about photons from non-thermal sources? A PV panel is able to generate electrical current from photons generated by LEDs, bioluminescence, and indirect light reflected off a cold surface.