Comment by xmprt

Comment by xmprt 2 days ago

6 replies

They're also paying $5M per year to maintain the servers and software. In theory they don't have to think about it but that just highlights the waste even more. I wish I could spend $5M without thinking.

gkoberger 2 days ago

CUNY's yearly budget is $5.7 billion, and they serve 243,000 students. It makes up 0.088% of their budget.

That $5M/year works out to $20/student/year, so in perspective it's a very small amount of money.

(Source: https://www.budget.ny.gov/pubs/archive/fy24/ex/agencies/appr...)

  • xmprt 2 days ago

    > so in perspective it's a very small amount of money

    $5M/year could pay for at least another 10-20 professors which is like an entirely new department. Let's also not forget the initial $600M spent which (assuming they'll use this software for the next 30 years) will be $20M/year bringing the total to $100/student/year which isn't negligible.

    More broadly speaking, I have a gripe with people bringing up percentages of budgets when discussing how much value something brings. My college had a startup fair where students pitched some super innovative ideas. The grand prize was $5000. If we had $5M, we could give that grand prize to 1000 teams and imagine how much more valuable that would be for the school compared to another feature bloated, overpriced piece of software.

    • gkoberger 2 days ago

      Okay, so if you hire 10-20 more professors... who's going to build and maintain the system so students can sign up for those classes?

      • bufferoverflow a day ago

        Programmers. You code the system once, it's not that complex, spend $10M max.

        Then you maintain it with a couple of senior devs at $1M/year max.

  • cipheredStones 2 days ago

    The one-letter omission of "k" in "$20k/student/year" really makes a difference here.

    • gkoberger 2 days ago

      No, $5M / 250,000 is $20. (I updated my comment to add a clause about $5M, to reduce confusion.)