Comment by lurking15

Comment by lurking15 2 days ago

3 replies

It's funny how (supposedly liberal) opponents of Trump will strategically whine about economic theory when generally otherwise if you were to make appeals on the basis of economics you're labelled heartless, etc.

You know what? I like when jobs are based in America because people need domestic careers that can sustain communities. There are non-monetary costs to outsourcing that are not mere quantities for an economist to decide for us.

Ross Perot was wildly successful running on a platform like this, at least relative to any other third party in American politics, and as soon as he appeared to be a threat to the establishment, strange stuff started happening to him much like the assassination attempts in this election.

resters 2 days ago

Heartless? In my view it is inappropriate for the government to prohibit or tax peaceful, voluntary activity such as trade.

The US grew economically due to the interstate commerce clause prohibiting states from imposing tariffs on each other, and now we are supposed to believe that Trump and Perot are economic geniuses because they want to subsidize coal extraction and tax EVs so that Americans have to pay double?

Most of the big wars started because countries got protectionist and isolated and had no economic reason not to fight each other.

  • lurking15 a day ago

    Yes it is heartless, because it's talking about complete dissolution of communities and swaths of the country due to corporate decisions that are all made under certain regulatory regimes and strategic policies of foreign nations (in many cases enemies). Look at H1B, I've never seen a good justification for it based on working in many large corporations, there's absolutely no reason we can't be finding actual citizens that could fill these jobs and build their careers.

    • resters 19 hours ago

      > finding actual citizens that could fill these jobs and build their careers.

      So then let's let them immigrate and gain citizenship!