Comment by fkyoureadthedoc

Comment by fkyoureadthedoc 3 days ago

8 replies

Alpine is great for your blog, but it's not even a little bit tempting for real world professional projects. Looking back at every project I've worked on there's no shot I would ever select Alpine for any of them.

These type of condescending comments really scream "I'm not even a web developer but here's my strong opinion as someone who only makes toy front ends to demo my data work"

pier25 3 days ago

Back in the day we did plenty of "real world professional projects" with jQuery.

I don't see why you couldn't with Alpine.

Yeah at some point you may need a more sophisticated solution but plenty of projects don't need React. This very forum you're using is just a very simple vanilla js file.

  • ramesh31 3 days ago

    >Back in the day we did plenty of "real world professional projects" with jQuery.

    And they were terribly unperformant, bug ridden, messes of spaghetti that I wouldn't wish on anyone in the year 2024. Things evolved past that for a reason.

    • sgarland 3 days ago

      Bold of you to assume that modern web dev isn’t also a terribly unperformant, bug-ridden mess of spaghetti.

      • pier25 16 hours ago

        Exactly.

        I've seen way more bloated React/Angular SPA apps than the typical PHP/jQuery Web 2.0 from back in the day.

  • fkyoureadthedoc 3 days ago

    > Back in the day we did plenty of "real world professional projects" with jQuery.

    I was there, it sucked

rmbyrro 3 days ago

An undesired level of condescendence for a message against it, no? My first impression...

zem 3 days ago

would you use one of these python-to-web frameworks like rio though? I think gp was just saying alpine was a good alternative to that.

  • fkyoureadthedoc 3 days ago

    Also 0 chance. Well maybe under some specific unrealistic constraints.

    But I am a fan of alternative approaches to the typical stuff just for the fun and learning aspect of it. I'd never come on here and be like "oh well that's cute, but it's useless, why can't we just x".

    For example I think Imba is pretty cool and I've used it for a couple throwaway personal projects just to give a spin, but I'd not use it at work.