rda2 2 days ago

It’s cute, and I’m trusting enough to believe them when it says 100% home made, but square images with a strong yellow tint will forever be associated with ChatGPT 4o image generation in my mind. Unfortunately, this might become something like the em-dash—where artists start tweaking their work to look less like the AI’s that are copying them.

  • Stratoscope 2 days ago

    > Unfortunately, this might become something like the em-dash—where artists start tweaking their work to look less like the AI’s that are copying them.

    So true! (And yes—I see what you did there.)

    It's even happening to photos now. A few months ago I posted a "Bot alert!" on Nextdoor warning people about the latest scambot.

    One person replied "It's funny to see a bot reporting a bot."

    I asked how they discovered I was a bot.

    "It's your profile photo. The facial expression is too good, and the smoothness of the background is too perfect. Has to be AI."

    For the curious, it's the same photo as on my LinkedIn:

    https://www.linkedin.com/in/michaelgeary/

    What they didn't know was how I took that selfie. I set up my Micro Four Thirds camera on a tripod in the front yard, with the world's best portrait lens: the Olympus 75mm f/1.8. I stood some 10-15 feet from it (this lens is equivalent to a 150mm lens on a full frame camera, i.e. a moderate telephoto) and used the remote control to take a few dozen shots as I let my face relax into various expressions.

    I picked out 4-5 favorites and asked a friend about them. She said "This one. It has gravitas."

    I don't even think it's that great a photo. But I suppose the "gravitas" makes it look like AI.

    For a photo that really shows off what that 75mm lens can do, check out this one of our late dog Brownie, titled Pumpkin Brownie:

    https://geary.smugmug.com/Pets/Dogs/i-dNMQW2v/A

    • savanaly 2 days ago

      Enjoyed your photos, thanks for explaining about how they were made.

  • presbyterian 2 days ago

    The cheese pattern and the green teacup pattern after it are obviously AI generated. The weird curve of the wedges, the fuzzy edges to the cheese holes, the artifacting around the edges of the teacups, the fact that neither is a perfectly repeating pattern. It's 100% AI, even if the font may not be.

    • mttch 2 days ago

      Even more obvious, look at the detail on the frame - it’s a unusual pattern that doesn’t repeat as you would expect.

  • parpfish 2 days ago

    In 15 years, the youths will become obsessed with that strange yellow cartoon style. They will crave that “vintage ChatGPT aesthetic”.

  • MrSkelter a day ago

    Your brain is cooked.

    LLM cliches are just condensed real world cliches.

    Work as middle of the road as this sits right at the heart of that. It’s supposed to be warm and it’s entirely digital, hence the ways of conveying warmth are the same.

    I have worked with Aardman. Unsurprisingly everything is shot digitally.

  • manIliketea 2 days ago

    100% Homemade is just a stock phrase that they are using to display the type-face. I don't think you should take that to mean anything more than "Feathers McGraw."

  • henrebotha 2 days ago

    > this might become something like the em-dash—where artists start tweaking their work to look less like the AI’s that are copying them.

    Literally how art has always worked

    • IAmBroom 2 days ago

      ... right up until July 9, 1962, when one Mr. Andrew Warhola upset the tradition.

      And pretty much ever since, too.

hamburglar 2 days ago

Is it intentional that the baseline vertical offset doesn’t seem consistent? Text set in this has a sort of up-and-down sloppy effect. Otherwise I love it.

Edit: it mostly seems that capitals appear higher than lowercase. It feels like there’s more inconsistency though, like the designer didn’t pay attention to eg the perceived “bottom” of curved characters vs flat-bottom ones.

  • inanutshellus 2 days ago

    IMO for a cartoon like W&G a little wonkiness and skew is entirely on-point.

  • ramses0 2 days ago

    Simply the "I" and "N" baselines on "Cracking" is wildly (un-professionally) off! Took a screenshot and there's +/- three pixels or so with no artistic justification for it. Even Comic Sans has a consistent baseline!

  • stronglikedan 2 days ago

    I was just coming here to say, it looks like each letter is about to fall over backwards.

  • fwip 2 days ago

    Doesn't seem like a ton of attention has been paid to kerning, either. The 'he' pair seems especially noticeable to me, which occurs several times in the "somewhere where there's cheese" image. I don't know enough about font design to guess whether the 'bad' kerning is intentional for the typeface, though - so I could be off base.

afavour 2 days ago

Really feel like this ought to have been named Wensleydale.

(this is awesome)

  • Night_Thastus 2 days ago

    EDIT: I'm wrong

    • Jarmsy 2 days ago

      Wensleydale is a place in Yorkshire, and a style of cheese, not specific to any one brand, so you could.

xnorswap 2 days ago

Was the crumpet buttered with "I can't believe it's not butter"?

( The typeface looks a lot like https://www.sainsburys.co.uk/gol-ui/product/i-cant-believe-i... )

  • undecisive 2 days ago

    It's interesting; I'd imagine very similar design briefs (friendliness, breadliness, etc)

    The ICBINB font is almost a semi-serif, almost like a sans serif that's slightly melted, whereas I'd say the crumpet is fully serif. The "e", "L" and "v" are pretty different. And I'd say the ICBINB font lends itself better to tighter spaces, whereas the crumpet font seems to beg for more space.

    But certainly, I could see one being used to replace another in a pinch - but I'm not a font specialist (graphologist? Is there a word for a person who studies fonts?)

  • pverheggen 2 days ago

    Nice find! That looks like Cooper Black, which the article cites as inspiration.

  • shoelessone 2 days ago

    There are a lot of similarities. You must either have a great memory for fonts, or eat a lot of butter alternative spread, either way good eye!

bloomingeek 2 days ago

I watched S1,Ep2 yesterday. When Wallace took down a picture of a pink pig to open the wall safe and then took out a pink piggy bank, I almost lost it. Classic!

jws 2 days ago

Just a note, if you want a special whimsical typeface, there are any number of talented folk on fiverr and similar that will make you one. Well worth it. For the cost of a lunch I got this turned into a font that I really like…

"Imagine an advanced alien race of octopus-like creatures who don't use writing. They encounter humans, enslave some and take them on their spaceships, but find they have to label things for the humans to read. Make me a font that is how these creatures would approximate our writing systems by miming the letters with their tentacles."

It's a glorious sinuous typeface which I use for labeling drawers and bins in my semi-industrial space.

You deserve your own personal typeface.

ordu 2 days ago

When I look at the text on the whole it seems that individual characters are not aligned properly, or maybe not vertical enough, or something like this. But when I look at individual characters to confirm it, I don't see any misalignment. How does it work?

  • kraftman 2 days ago

    Yeah they looked like they were wobbling while I read them until I focused on them more.

shrikant 2 days ago

That's beautiful, I'd love a monospaced variant of this to replace Comic Mono in my IDE/Fira Mono in my terminal. IANA font expert though, would that even be possible?

cush 2 days ago

Fonts are such an underappreciated art form. Love this

Zee2 a day ago

The kerning on this makes me itchy. Everything seems oddly spaced.

chihuahua 2 days ago

It's halfway between Comic Sans and the 1970s "Groovy" font.

k_kiki 2 days ago

It's quite round and looks pretty good.

barcodehorse 2 days ago

There's a miniscule dent on the top of the capital B that's really bothering me. Idk, I know everyone's a critic, but it just doesnt sit right with me

  • shermantanktop 2 days ago

    I clearly don't have refined appreciation of visual typographic nuance because I do not see this at all.

gregjw 2 days ago

hey! a local designer. this looks great.