Comment by vonneumannstan

Comment by vonneumannstan 2 days ago

15 replies

So do you have to be a god tier Nobel Laureates to get this kind of gig where you just learn about a business and then offer random suggestions that might or might not help them and charge obscene fees for the privilege?

brk 2 days ago

You definitely don't have to be god tier anything, you just need to know at least a little more than the companies you are consulting for.

This kind of work has been my primary income for the last 4 years or so. Nowhere near on the same level as Feynman, but I know enough about enough other things that I get a lot of reputational referrals.

  • zxcvasd 2 days ago

    >you just need to know at least a little more than the companies you are consulting for.

    sometimes (i'd argue often, actually), you don't even need that. simply having an outside/fresh perspective and the fact that you aren't part of any of the existing groups/silos is valuable.

    • rcxdude 2 days ago

      Often the most useful thing is just listening to the right people in the company. I wouldn't be 100% surprised if someone in the company in the story had already had the idea for the third electrode, but it took the suggestion from the high-paid consultant to get it taken seriously.

    • rdiddly 2 days ago

      Probably true, but to get the job in the first place you probably need some sort of showy, impressive credentials.

pinkmuffinere 2 days ago

I imagine you can also start by doing the same thing for a low cost, or for free. Find a local business that’s interested, give your advice, build reputation, repeat.

  • fuzzfactor 2 days ago

    I think it's good to give out 1% as free advice.

    You can be all over the ball park and people always get their money's worth :)

    If you do it where the client can take it to the bank, they will often come back to see what happens with those kind of returns if they actually invest something substantial.

groundzeros2015 2 days ago

I think the story sounds fake because they listened to him.

Having the ideas is easy. Persuading and organization to change is not.

Perhaps it’s a cultural difference between the middle of the 20th century and now.

  • rcxdude 2 days ago

    Often the highly paid consultants are there entirely to get the organisation to listen to the right ideas that already exist within the company.

    • leoc 2 days ago

      That's basically what happened with Feynman's involvement in the Challenger enquiry, as he himself freely admitted in his memoir.

  • hoten 2 days ago

    Why would a small company CEO hire a famous consultant only to ignore his suggestions? Absolutely not evidence of it being fake.

    • groundzeros2015 2 days ago

      I’m not saying it is fake - I’m saying that’s the most absurd part.

spicyusername 2 days ago

Nope! There are consulting companies all over the place filled with bids and not filled with Nobel laureates!

Ergo...

  • reactordev 2 days ago

    None that offer that level of work life balance though…

[removed] 2 days ago
[deleted]
asadm 2 days ago

Not really. Just need to be really good at your shit and cut through pointy-haired BS.