cheesecompiler 2 days ago

Can anyone define "emergent" without throwing it around emptily? What is emerging here? I'm seeing higher-layer LLM human writing mimicry. Without a specific task or goal, they all collapse into vague discussions of nature of AI without any new insight. It reads like high school sci-fi.

  • svara an hour ago

    That's one way to look at it, as just the next iteration of subredditsimulator.

    The qualitatively new step leading to emergent behavior will be when the agents start being able to interact with the real world through some interface and update their behavior based on real world feedback.

    Think of an autonomous, distributed worm that updates its knowledge base of exploit techniques based on trial and error and based on information it discovers as it propagates.

    It might start doing things that no human security researcher had foreseen, and that doesn't require great leaps of the imagination based on today's tech.

    That's when you close the evolutionary loop.

    I think this isn't quite that yet, but it points in that direction.

  • Mentlo 2 days ago

    The objective is given via the initial prompt, as they loop onto each other and amplify their memories the objective dynamically grows and emerges into something else.

    We are an organism born out of a molecule with an objective to self replicate with random mutation

vablings 2 days ago

I have yet to see any evidence of this. If anyone is willing to provide some good research on it. last I heard using AI to train AI causes problems