Comment by direwolf20

Comment by direwolf20 3 days ago

6 replies

They say that most fascist governments fall apart because they actively despise competence, which it turns out you need if you are trying to run a country.

bena 3 days ago

That’s because eventually reality catches up to you.

If the reality of a thing is in opposition to the regime’s wishes, you can’t just wish that away.

However, the regime will favor those who say “yes” over those who accept reality.

PearlRiver 3 days ago

Competence gives way to ideology.

I once read an interesting book on the economy of Nazi Germany. There were a lot of smart CEOs and high ranking civil servants who perfectly predicted US industrial might.

coldtea 3 days ago

They say it, but they're wrong. Historically speaking there have been basically about 2 fascist governments, and they fell because they lost wars. And Germany, for one, did run them with high competence, to the extend that it took years for many countries to do anything about.

It we loosen "fascist" to just mean any authoritarian government, there are many that run of very long time.

  • thinkingtoilet 3 days ago

    WWII started in 1939 and was done in early 1945, so it didn't take that long.

    More importantly, maybe the Nazi's were competent at first, but they absolutely fell apart internally due to mistrust, back stabbing, and demanding of loyalty above all else. Hitler famously made many poor military decisions.

    • coldtea 2 days ago

      Six years for a country holding back the allies is not "that long" - and 6 years more since they came into power?

      And as a government they'd still be in power 20 and 30 years later if they didn't start the war (judging from Franco's spain).

    • direwolf20 3 days ago

      The Nazis were in power for years before they started WWII.