Comment by Der_Einzige
Comment by Der_Einzige 4 days ago
I'll straight up accuse them of on purpose muddying the waters. To get to the point of executing a successful training run like that, you have to count every failed experiment and experiment that gets you to the final training run. They spent well over 100 Million to train this model by that definition, and all definitions which don't include the failed runs up to the successful one at the end are at best disingenuous and at worst outright lies designed to trick investors into dumping Nvidia.
No, deepseek did not spend only 5.5 million for Deepseek V3. No Gemini was not "entirely trained on TPUs". They did hundreds of experiments on GPUs to get to the final training run done entirely on TPUs. GCP literally has millions of GPUs and you bet your ass that the gemini team has access to them and uses them daily. Deepseek total cost to make Deepseek V3 is also in the 100-400 million range when you count all of what's needed to get to the final training run.
Edit: (Can't post cus this site's "posting too fast" thing is really stupid/bad)
The only way I can get reliable information out of folks like you is to loudly proclaim something wrong on the internet. I'm just going to even more aggressively do that from now on to goad people like you to set the record straight.
Even if they only used TPUs, they sure as shit spent orders of magnitude more than they claim due to "count the failed runs too"
> No Gemini was not "entirely trained on TPUs". They did hundreds of experiments on GPUs to get to the final training run done entirely on TPUs. GCP literally has millions of GPUs and you bet your ass that the gemini team has access to them and uses them daily.
You are wrong. Gemini was definitely trained entirely on TPU. Of course your point of "you need to count failed experiments, too". Is correct. But you seem to have misconceptions around how deepmind operates and what infra it possess. Deepmind (or barely any of Google internal stuff) runs on Borg, an internal cloud system, which is completely separate (and different) from gcp. Deepmind does not have access to any meaningful gcp resources. And Borg barely has any GPUs. At the time I left deepmind, the amount of tpu compute available was probably 1000x to 10000x larger than the amount of gpu compute. You would never even think of seriously using GPUs for neural net training, it's too limited (in terms of available compute) and expensive (in terms of internal resource allocation units), and frankly less well supported by internal tooling than tpu. Even for small, short experiments, you would always use TPUs.