Comment by ifwinterco

Comment by ifwinterco 5 days ago

2 replies

Yep people will pay rates in "high tax" US states where you're still only paying ~40% ish total income tax and they're really nice places to live.

That would still be considered a fair and reasonable level of tax by european standards.

Obviously there is a level though - if you made it 95% then people would leave. I don't think there's any reasonable argument that the level doesn't exist, the question is where is it for a specific place at a specific time

thinkingtoilet 4 days ago

95% on what? Income over a million dollars. Income over 10 million dollars? If you like living in a super liberal state and super liberal city like Boston, you're not going to move to Texas just because you're getting taxed higher. Rich people are still absurdly rich, I feel like that gets lost in these discussions. These taxes don't materially effect them in anyway but have massive benefits for society.

  • ifwinterco 4 days ago

    Rich people tend to actually be penny pinchers in my experience and most will object to 95% income tax out of principle.

    You could say "well good riddance" but taxing $10mn of income at 20% raises a lot more useful money than taxing $0 of income at 95%