Comment by kelnos

Comment by kelnos 5 days ago

(xfwl4 author here.)

That's a fair criticism sometimes, but, frankly, if you want things the way you want them, learn to code and dig in. Otherwise it's not really fair of you to complain about stuff that people have built for you for free, in their spare time.

In this particular case, it's not fully a "new and shiny, must play!" situation. I personally am not even a big fan of Wayland, and I'm generally highly critical of it. But Xorg is more or less unmaintained, and frankly, if we don't have a Wayland compositor, we'll become obsolete eventually. That's just the way the wind is blowing.

uecker 5 days ago

I am not complaining about what people do in their spare time. If the blog post said "someone does this because he likes to spend his own time on it", I would not complain. I am complaining about a) the justifications given which I think are all nonsense IMHO and rationalizations for something which some likes to do, and b) the use of donations which should be better used to improve the software instead of creating more rewrites.

I also do not agree with the Wayland is inevitable sentiment. There are non-systemd distros, there will also be non-Wayland distros. The idea is that only those things survive which are pushed into the ecosystem by the cooperate bullies is wrong, otherwise Linux would not exist.

The Linux desktop was essentially fine already two decades ago and instead of the needed refinements, bug fixing, and polishments, we get random changes in technology after the other, so nothing ever really improves but we incrementally lose applications which do not keep up, break workflows, sometimes even regress in technology (network transparency), and discourage people from investing into applications because the base is not stable. My hope was that Xfce4 is different, but apparently this was unfounded.

Reply View 2 replies

kelnos 5 days ago

> I am not complaining about what people do in their spare time.
Re-read your original post. You are absolutely complaining about what we do in our spare time.
> If the blog post said "someone does this because he likes to spend his own time on it", I would not complain.
I mean, that's part of it. I wouldn't do it if I wasn't interested in doing it. I have my own long list of Wayland criticisms, but I think it's interesting.
> I also do not agree with the Wayland is inevitable sentiment.
I think that's where we'll be at an impasse.
There are non-systemd distros because there are viable alternatives. Xorg (the server implementation, I mean, not X11 the protocol/system) is dead. I don't like saying that. I've invested a lot of time into X11 and understanding how it works, and how Xorg works. But no one wants to maintain it. There is the XLibre fork, and I wish them well, and do want them to succeed, but sustaining a fork is hard, and only time will tell if that works out.
But I don't think X11 has a future, unfortunately. And that really does make me sad. You're free to disagree with that, but... well, so what.
> The Linux desktop was essentially fine already two decades ago and instead of the needed refinements
That's a view through rose-tinted glasses if I ever saw one.
> we get random changes in technology after the other
Jamie Zawinski called this the "Cascade of Attention-Deficit Teenagers", and he's right. I do think some of these changes are an earnest and honest attempt to make things better, but yes, people just want to work on what interests them, and what makes them feel good and accomplished.
When we work for a corporation we don't really get to do that, but when it's unpaid, spare-time volunteer work, we have the freedom to do whatever makes us happy, even if it makes other people mad or disappointed or annoyed, or isn't the most "productive" use of our time (whatever that means).
::shrug::

Reply View | 1 reply
- uecker 4 days ago
  
  > > I am not complaining about what people do in their spare time.
  > Re-read your original post. You are absolutely complaining about what we do in our spare time.
  Then I am not sure how I have to understand this sentence: "After careful consideration, we’ve decided on a meaningful way to use the generous donations from our community: funding longtime Xfce core developer Brian Tarricone to create xfwl4, a brand-new Wayland compositor for Xfce."
  
  Reply View | 0 replies

RunSet 4 days ago

> That's just the way the wind is blowing.

I trust you understand that some readers may not find (to paraphrase) "I don't like it either but it is what it is." a compelling reason to fix something that is not broken.

Reply View 1 reply

uecker 4 days ago

I also do not use free software to then have to use something I do not like because the "this is the way the wind is blowing" (just becomes some parts of the industry wants something re-engineered in their interests)

Reply View | 0 replies