Comment by ajnin

Comment by ajnin 5 days ago

3 replies

Everyday the world is becoming more polarized. Technology corporations gain ever more control over people's lives, telling people what they can do on their computers and phones, what they can talk about on social platforms, censoring what they please, wielding the threat of being cutoff from their data, their social circles on a whim. All over the world, in dictatorships and also in democratic countries, governments turn more fascist and more violent. They demonstrate that they can use technology to oppress their population, to hunt dissent and to efficiently spread propaganda.

In that world, authoring technology that enables this even more is either completely mad or evil. To me Linux is not a technological object, it is also a political statement. It is about choice, personal freedom, acceptance of risk. If you build software that actively intends to take this away from me to put it into the hands of economic interests and political actors then you deserve all the hate you can get.

TacticalCoder 5 days ago

> To me Linux is not a technological object, it is also a political statement. It is about choice, personal freedom ...

I use Linux since the Slackware day. Poettering is the worse thing that happened to the Linux ecosystem and, of course, he went on to work for Microsoft. Just to add a huge insult to the already painful injury.

This is not about security for the users. It's about control.

At least many in this thread are criticizing the project.

And, once again of course, it's from a private company.

Full of ex-Microsofties.

I don't know why anyone interested in hacking would cheer for this. But then maybe HN should be renamed "CN" (Corporate News) or "MN" (Microsoft News).

  • blibble 5 days ago

    > Poettering is the worse thing that happened to the Linux ecosystem and, of course, he went on to work for Microsoft. Just to add a huge insult to the already painful injury.

    agreed, and now he's planning on controlling what remains of your machine cryptographically!

  • egorfine 4 days ago

    > I use Linux since the Slackware day. Poettering is the worse thing that happened to the Linux ecosystem

    Same here, Linux since about 1995. Same opinion.

    > And, once again of course, it's from a private company. Full of ex-Microsofties.

    And funded. And confident they will sell the product well.