simulator5g 5 days ago

Haven’t you heard? Laws don’t apply to companies

  • groundzeros2015 5 days ago

    [flagged]

    • free_bip 5 days ago

      You are on a website called HackerNews, where people are encouraged to comment on articles or "posts". You are seeing this because you are looking at the comment section of one such post.

      • groundzeros2015 2 days ago

        political quips with no insight or information used to be considered against the rules and removed.

knowitnone3 5 days ago

Illegal in what way? They are not allowed to set prices lower than competitors or raise them at any time?

  • arrosenberg 5 days ago

    Predatory pricing is illegal in the US, but difficult to prosecute under the existing laws.

    • twoodfin 5 days ago

      What is “predatory pricing” vs. “pricing”?

      • giaour 5 days ago

        Selling items for less than they cost to produce is known as "dumping" in international trade (where it is generally disallowed by trade organizations) and can be illegal in the US if the intent is to eliminate competition [0]. That last factor can be hard to prove, and I don't think the FTC is doing much about anticompetitive behavior these days.

        [0]: https://www.ftc.gov/advice-guidance/competition-guidance/gui...

      • mcmcmc 5 days ago

        To add onto sibling comment: it is specifically when they sell below cost to eliminate competition, with the goal of later being able to raise prices to recover those losses (and more) once they are the only player in town and can jack the prices up all they want. The later price elevations are what result in consumer harm, which is why it is illegal.

      • bmurphy1976 5 days ago

        Predatory pricing:

        A big gorilla comes in and under prices the entire market. They can do that because they already have tons of money. They do this long enough to break the market and drive the competition out of business. Once the competitors are gone they jack up the prices to unprecedented levels because there's no more alternatives available and bleed the market for all the money.

        Regular pricing:

        Charge a fair price based on actual costs.

      • [removed] 5 days ago
        [deleted]
    • taurath 5 days ago

      Which means it’s actually: legal and widespread

      • conception 5 days ago

        No it means it’s illegal and enforcement agencies don’t have the means and/or political support to prosecute.

  • selcuka 5 days ago

    > Amazon duped his product and sold it at something crazy, like half price

    Pricing below an appropriate measure of cost is generally considered predatory pricing. It is very difficult to enforce this, but that doesn't change the fact that it could be illegal and a violation of antitrust laws.

    • sincerely 5 days ago

      Amazon could also have the resources/know-how/volume to manufacture a comparable product that could be sold for half the cost

      • spockz 5 days ago

        Then that is okay as long as they don’t raise the prices after the competition is gone.