Comment by delusional

Comment by delusional a day ago

5 replies

Don't ask me to elaborate on this, because it's kinda nebulous in my mind. I think there's a difference between being given an insight and interrogating that on your own initiative, and being given the same insight.

gchamonlive a day ago

I don't doubt there is a difference in the mechanism of arriving at a given connection. What I think it's not possible to distinguish is the connection that someone made intuitively after reading many sources and the one that the AI makes, because both will have to undergo scrutiny before being accepted as relevant. We can argue there could be a difference in quality, depth and search space, maybe, but I don't think there is an ontological difference.

  • fwip a day ago

    The one that you thought of in the shower has a much greater chance of being right, and also of being relevant to you.

    • gchamonlive 15 hours ago

      Has it? Why?

      • fwip 7 hours ago

        Because humans aren't morons tasked with coming up with 100 connections.

        • gchamonlive 6 hours ago

          Doesn't explain why a connection made in the shower has in essence more merit than a connection an LLM was instructed to come up with.