Comment by busymom0

Comment by busymom0 5 days ago

7 replies

I want to try once again to learn piano. Previously, many years ago, I took lessons for 1.5 years but gave up because it was just too hard and I wasn't enjoying it. This time, I plan on trying to self learn. Been watching YouTube tutorials recently and as soon as I return from my trip, I will try once again.

I have bought the Nancy Faber adult piano adventures book 1 too.

Any tips are welcome.

mmcconnell1618 5 days ago

Learning to play individual notes from sheet music only helps you learn one song. The breakthrough for me was thinking in musical structure.

- There are 12 keys on the piano just repeated - A scale can start on any of those 12 keys - The "home" key of the scale get labels with a roman numeral one, I - The rest of the keys in the scale get roman numerals ii,iii,IV,V,vi,vii - The I,IV,V are all upper case to represent major chords, the lower case for minor chords - Most pop songs use I,IV,V from a scale. In C-major scale, C, F, G major chords. - You can start on any key on the piano and if you play the same sequence of I, IV, V, you'll get the same song, just transposed into a different key. (the scales are slightly different due to even temperament for advanced ears)

So, learn songs by the chord structure first. It is easier to remember and you'll start to recognize patterns in other songs and unlock them faster.

  • quantpunk 4 days ago

    After playing guitar for 25 years, I quit guitar and got a digital piano.

    I practiced enough to learn to play Satie - Gnossienne No. 1 in the right hand and then sold the piano.

    My fav music is Chopin, Satie, Ravel, Debussy, Rachmaninoff, Ligeti on piano.

    The distance between starting from zero on the guitar, to anything ever composed for the guitar is a 100X less than starting from zero on piano to Ligeti.

    Learning to solo on electric guitar, play the flute, play the alto sax to me makes so much more sense than trying to learn to play piano or classical guitar as an adult. Classical guitar is hard enough. Piano is just a whole other level to that.

    A monophonic instrument is just going to be so much better bang for the buck in terms of time woodshedding. Or a percussion instrument.

  • greenie_beans 4 days ago

    > Most pop songs use I,IV,V from a scale

    this is the blues. just learn how to play a blues progression on the piano and you'll learn what this poster is trying to teach.

kuerbel 5 days ago

What was too hard if I may ask? Maybe your teacher focused on the wrong things for/with you?

tmseidman 5 days ago

Me too! I'm using Alfred's Adult Piano course book.

  • busymom0 5 days ago

    Have you started yet? How is it going? Self learning?

    • tmseidman 3 days ago

      Nope, haven't started yet, since I'm out of town and my keyboard is at home. But yeah, I'll be self-learning! I did it with guitar a few years ago and it worked for me (to a point; I never got amazing at guitar).