Comment by impossiblefork 2 days ago
Fanfic reading is not like novel reading in that you don't need to really understand new, unfamiliar characters though.
Thus it can tend to become limiting; and I say this as someone who actually does enjoy fanfiction.
>Also, I thought that Yudkowsky's HPMOR fanfic had more interesting ideas than the whole Rowling series, which I like a lot.
Then you do not understand writing. If Yudkowski really had more interesting ideas, then he would have been able to do HPMOR as original fiction.
Rowling is actually really good, inventing very charming things, very fun sentences, and there's nothing even close in HPMOR (I have read it myself, and enjoyed it to some degree), but you really underestimate how good Rowling is.
Yeah I thought it was such a funny example yo pick out bc, yes it is!
> Fanfic reading is not like novel reading in that you don't need to really understand new, unfamiliar characters though.
So the Lord of the Rings series counts as one book? I'd believe diminishing returns, but not one and done.
Also, I thought that Yudkowsky's HPMOR fanfic had more interesting ideas than the whole Rowling series, which I like a lot.