Comment by unscaled

Let's revisit the original article[1]. It was not about arguments, but about the pain of writing callbacks and even async/await compared to writing the same code in Go. It had 5 well-defined claims about languages with colored functions:

1. Every function has a color.

This is true for the new zig approach: functions that deal with IO are red, functions that do not need to deal with IO are blue.

2. The way you call a function depends on its color.

This is also true for Zig: Red functions require an Io argument. Blue functions do not. Calling a red function means you need to have an Io argument.

3. You can only call a red function from within another red function.

You cannot call a function that requires an Io object in Zig without having an Io in context.

Yes, in theory you can use a global variable or initialize a new Io instance, but this is the same as the workarounds you can do for calling an async function from a non-async function For instance, in C# you can write 'Task.Run(() -> MyAsyncMethod()).Wait()'.

4. Red functions are more painful to call.

This is true in Zig again, since you have to pass down an Io instance.

You might say this is not a big nuisance and almost all functions require some argument or another... But by this measure, async/await is even less troublesome. Compare calling an async function in Javascript to an Io-colored function in Zig:

  function foo() {
    blueFunction(); // We don't add anything
  }

  async function bar() {
    await redFunction(); // We just add "await"
  }

And in Zig:

  fn foo() void {
    blueFunction()
  }

  fn bar(io: Io) void {
    redFunction(io); // We just add "io".
  }

Zig is more troublesome since you don't just add a fixed keyword: you need a add a variable that is passed along through somewhere.

5. Some core library functions are red.

This is also true in Zig: Some core library functions require an Io instance.

I'm not saying Zig has made the wrong choice here, but this is clearly not colorless I/O. And it's ok, since colorless I/O was always just hype.

---

[1] https://journal.stuffwithstuff.com/2015/02/01/what-color-is-...