Comment by nickm12

This is yet another very good critique, but it's long past time that we stop paying attention to Uncle Bob.

Not only are his ideas about how to write software patently bad, but he is willfully obtuse when asked to provide nuance or discuss trade-offs. John Ousterhout's dialog with him, published as "A Philosophy of Software Design vs Clean Code" gave him every opportunity to think critically about his own suggestions and he just doubles down.

https://github.com/johnousterhout/aposd-vs-clean-code/blob/m...

He's just trolling us at this point.