Comment by morshu9001 2 days ago
I've gone the all-JSON route many times, and pretty soon it starts getting annoying enough that I lament not using protos. I'm actually against static types in languages, but the API is one place they really matter (the other is the DB). Google made some unforced mistakes on proto usability/popularity though.
Sounds like this introduced behavior changes. How did you evaluate if the new behavior was desirable or not? I’ve definitely run into cases where the missing fields were load bearing in ways the types would not suggest, so I never take it for granted that type error in prod code = bug
The most terrifying systems to maintain are the ones that work accidentally. If what you describe is actually desired behavior, I hope you have good tests! For my part, I’ll take types that prevent load-bearing absences from arising in the first place, because that sounds like a nightmare.
Although, an esoteric language defined in terms of negative space might be interesting. A completely empty source file implements “hello world” because you didn’t write a main function. All integers are incremented for every statement that doesn’t include them. Your only variables are the ones you don’t declare. That kind of thing.
it was desirable because our reason for the conversion was subtle bugs all over the place where data was disappearing.
It costs time, distracts some devs, and adds complexity for negligible safety improvement. Especially if/when the types end up being used everywhere because managers like that metric. I get using types if you have no tests, but you really need tests either way. I've done the opposite migration before, TS to JS.
Oh I forgot to qualify that I'm only talking about high level code, not things that you'd use C or Rust for. But part of the reason those langs have static types is they need to know sizes on stack at compile time.
why are you against static types in languages?
I once converted a fairly large JS codebase to TS and I found about 200 mismatching names/properties all over the place. Tons of properties we had nulls suddenly started getting values.