Comment by ivell

Comment by ivell 2 days ago

4 replies

Like any business Apple needs growth to satisfy the shareholders. New growth would come from India and China. Apple didn't leave China and neither it will leave India. India can and will survive without Apple. Though having it in the country would be good for optics.

The moment mobile companies locked down sideloading, ability to uninstall bundled software, etc., they made it impossible to argue techincally against bundled, uninstallable software from the government.

JumpCrisscross 2 days ago

> Apple didn't leave China and neither it will leave India. India can and will survive without Apple

They can both survive without each other. But neither is going to break the arrangement without a lot of pain. They have mutual leverage with each other, and that becomes particularly material when one stops treating India as a monolith.

> India can and will survive without Apple. Though having it in the country would be good for optics

Most people aren't content with merely surviving.

  • ivell 2 days ago

    > Most people aren't content with merely surviving.

    I think you overestimate the importance of Apple to India. It is just a company. And actually not the biggest employer or most tax paying one either.

    Apple is not the only vendor in India and has also not the most sold phone.

    • JumpCrisscross 2 days ago

      > you overestimate the importance of Apple to India. It is just a company

      If New Delhi wants to smite Apple it obviously can. That isn’t the question. It’s if Apple can bargain for a better deal. I think the answer is yes.

      The starting point would be finding the fault lines between the folks in India arguing for this policy and those who don’t care or are hostile to it.

wiz21c a day ago

You say "Like any business Apple needs growth to satisfy the shareholders." like it is acceptable.