Comment by grayhatter

Comment by grayhatter 2 days ago

1 reply

> We used the steam engine for 100 years before we had a firm understanding of why it worked. We still don’t understand how ice skating works. We don’t have a physical understanding of semi-fluid flow in grain silos, but we’ve been using them since prehistory.

I don't think you and I are using the same definition for "firm understanding" or "how it works".

> I could go on and on. The world around you is full of not well understood technology, as well as non deterministic processes. We know how to engineer around that.

Again, you're side stepping my argument so you can restate things that are technically correct, but not really a point in of themselves. I see people who want to call themselves software engineers throw code they clearly don't understand against the wall because the AI said so. There's a significant delta between knowing you can heat water to turn it into a gas with increased pressure that you can use to mechanically turn a wheel, vs, put wet liquid in jar, light fire, get magic spinny thing. If jar doesn't call you a funny name first, that's bad!

adastra22 2 days ago

> I don't think you and I are using the same definition for "firm understanding" or "how it works".

I’m standing in firm ground here. Debate me in the details if you like.

You are constructing a strawman.