JumpCrisscross 2 days ago

> for every theory of relativity the is the religious non-sense and superstitions of the medieval ages or today

If Einstein came up with relativity by standing on "the religious non-sense and superstitions of the medieval ages," you'd have a point.

  • Ajakks a day ago

    Well, "spooky action at a distance" is something that believing outright at the time, literally required faith - much like the faith required of scientist today, everything comes from nothing for no reason and without cause and as consequence - everything everywhere... Ohhh!!! and like 11 dimensions with maybe infinite universes, too -> oh yeah, and the universe is infinite, maybe.

    They have so many ways of saying "God" without saying God.

  • scotty79 2 days ago

    If we have billions of AIs one might pick the correct learning materials. Same way human Einstein did.

    • teiferer a day ago

      Depends what you mean with "AI". Actual intelligence? Yeah, maybe. LLM? No, they don't actually reason, an activity that Einstein did a lot of and without which coming up with his theory would have been impossible. He didn't just go on a random walk like what LLM temperature is doing.

      • scotty79 a day ago

        Who knew that such a huge amount of software development problems can be solved without ever "actually" reasoning.

        • mrbungie a day ago

          Well, depends on the software project itself and where you are in its development lifecycle but:

          - (1) A lot of developing can be just chores around managing scaffolds and repeatable work, and due to this macros, autogenerated code and other tools have been a thing at many layers for a long time; and

          - (2) I remember copy-pasting from Google/StackOverflow (i.e. mostly search + pattern matching with some minimal reasoning) being criticized as a low-effort mode of development during the 2010s, before ChatGPT and AI assisted coding tools took over that part.

          So yes, I'd argue a huge amount of software development problems can be solved without ever actually reasoning from first principles, AI tools just made that more visible.

flir 2 days ago

I know we're just pointlessly abusing the analogy here, but... mediaeval cathedrals are a greater work of artifice than pyramids.