Comment by qcnguy
I didn't claim otherwise. It should however be self evident that courts have no solid basis on which to make such a call. Judges don't know anything about running power plants, hiring employees, or really anything on that matter.
This is why human rights laws are always terrible in practice. They require the courts to make decisions well outside the bounds of their expertise.
> Judges don't know anything about running power plants, hiring employees, or really anything on that matter.
This is why both parties hire the best lawyers they can, and the best expert witnesses, to make the case for their side. We cannot require that every decision in the world be made by experts in the decision domain - sometimes they have to be made by people we've entrusted to make decisions (and in particular, decisions intended to be guided by the law).