Comment by tstrimple

Comment by tstrimple 4 days ago

I think you’re ignoring a huge factor in how radiative cooling actually works. I thought the initial question was fine if you hadn’t read the article but understand the downvotes due to doubling down. Think of it this way. Why do thermoses have a vacuum sealed chamber between two walls in order to insulate the contents of the bottle? Because a vacuum is a fucking terrible heat convector. Putting your data center into space in order to cool it is like putting a computer inside of a thermos to cool it. It makes zero fucking sense. There is nowhere for the heat to actually radiate to so it stays inside.

foobarian 4 days ago

Pardon but this doesn't make sense to me. A 1 m^2 radiator in space can eliminate almost a kilowatt of heat.

>vacuum is a fucking terrible heat convector

Yes we're talking about radiating not convection

Reply View 3 replies

wat10000 4 days ago

At what temperature?
And a kilowatt from one square meter is awful. You can do far more than that with access to an atmosphere, never mind water.

Reply View | 0 replies
kergonath 3 days ago

> A 1 m^2 radiator in space can eliminate almost a kilowatt of heat.
Assuming that this is the right order of magnitude, a 8MW datacenter discussed upthread would require ~8000 m^2, plus a fancy way of getting the heat there.
A kilowatt is nothing. The workstation on my desk can sustain 1 kW.

Reply View | 1 reply
- mercutio2 3 days ago
  
  Why are you assuming active heat transfer? Passive is the way to go.
  
  Reply View | 0 replies