Comment by lylo

Comment by lylo 7 hours ago

3 replies

De-Appleing is very difficult if you have a family using iCloud Photos, music, drive etc.

Looking at the list, perhaps moving documents off iCloud Drive (to where? Dropbox? That isn’t E2E is it?) and Notes is enough.

Do I really care if my photos are E2E encrypted? Most of my photos are in Lightroom cloud so those are not anyway.

I don’t use reminders or Freeform or voice memos, and I couldn’t care less about safari bookmarks. If I move off Drive and Notes, I don’t really care about iCloud backup either.

Is this sufficient? My notes will go to Obsidian (except some disposable shared ones) but where do I move my documents if not on iCloud Drive? Is Dropbox any better?

bean469 7 hours ago

> De-Appleing is very difficult if you have a family using iCloud Photos, music, drive etc.

Although this is just anecdata, I moved my senior parents from iCloud Photos to Immich recently and their response was something like:

"Wow, the new Photos program on the iPad looks nice!"

For them it works out fine, since their use-cases are checking out vacation photos by scrolling the timeline and also occasionally clicking on the "memories" from N years ago. Helps that the app icon is very similar, too.

  • lylo 5 hours ago

    Thanks. Looks good, although perhaps Ente has the edge with things like facial recognition (I know this is a big draw for family with Apple Photos)

neop1x 4 hours ago

Self-host. NextCloud & Ente are great alternatives.