Comment by verdverm

Comment by verdverm 13 hours ago

2 replies

> Do you dispute the homicide rate I mentioned?

You didn't mention any rate prior and you provide no supporting evidence, multiple sources for each is preferred. Is this supposed 60x higher rate per day or per person?

and as others have said, comparing a city (urban) to a whole country (mixed) is silly

janalsncm 13 hours ago

The rate is per 100k people over a year, which is how homicide rates are usually reported. To my understanding, these numbers aren’t disputed.

Singapore is a city and NYC is a city. Of course no comparison will be perfect, but the significant difference in safety will not go away through clever accounting.

  • verdverm 11 hours ago

    you haven't provided any citations for "significant"

    not going to believe a stranger from an internet forum saying 60x

    severe punishments are more likely the defining factor than gov't type