Comment by pizlonator

Comment by pizlonator 7 hours ago

3 replies

Fil-C running on any x86 box is faster than any CHERI implementation that has ever existed.

That's likely to be true in embedded also, just because of the relationship between volume and performance in silicon. Fil-C runs on the high volume stuff, so it'll get better perf.

CHERI doubles the size of pointers, so it's not like it has a decisive advantage over Fil-C.

Findecanor 6 hours ago

> Fil-C running on any x86 box is faster than any CHERI implementation that has ever existed.

Heh. I don't doubt it. Just like RISC-V in QEmu on a x86 box is faster than any RISC-V core that anyone can get their hands on ... but only so far.

checker659 6 hours ago

Do you even have access to CHERI hardware Phil?

  • pizlonator 6 hours ago

    No, and I don't need to in order to know that my claim is accurate.

    Also, the fact that having access to CHERI hardware is a thing you presume I don't have should tell you a lot about how likely CHERI is to ever succeed