Comment by skybrian

Comment by skybrian a day ago

5 replies

Many interesting statements aren't a property of the code alone. They're a property of the code when it's run in a particular environment. If you want the proof to be portable then it should only make assumptions that are true in any environment.

dapperdrake a day ago

No assumption holds for all environments.

Posh example: Axiom of choice.

  • naasking a day ago

    There are definitely some assumptions that hold for all environments. For instance, "all resources are finite".

    • eszed a day ago

      Aye, but in many cases a theoretical limit can be ignored in practice. (Stupid example: I need more cooling = "I need more fans", not "I'm running out of air".)

      • naasking 17 hours ago

        Finite resources are a common problem though.

        • lstodd 10 hours ago

          Stupidity is known to be infinite. And it is a resource.