Comment by CamperBob2

Comment by CamperBob2 18 hours ago

9 replies

The obvious next step is to train a model to turn these detailed updates into realistic live-action video.

Of course, the obvious step after that is for MLB to shit a brick and shut down the API.

altairprime 18 hours ago

Perhaps not posting the “here’s how to destroy a nice thing” ideas, which makes them more widely known and thus more likely to be created by someone, would help reduce the incidences of “nice thing destroyed”. That next step towards destruction is never quite as obvious to everyone as you think. Sure, a few people have probably thought of it, but odds are they won’t do anything about it. Sharing them widely like this is like leading a flash mob to hold up lightning rods in a thunderstorm and saying “it would be such a shame if lightning struck one of us”.

k2enemy 17 hours ago

It seems like MLB themselves have been experimenting with this. On their website, they have a feature called "gameday" that animates the game. For a while now they've had a 2d view, but now they also have a 3d view that you can switch to.

It is buggy as hell, but neat that you can move around the field and watch player movement off the ball. But there are a ton of glitches, like players getting frozen or duplicated, batters, umps, and catchers getting swapped (funny to see the ump at bat), and mixups with mount visits. In time, I can imagine this as a great way to watch though. Especially for novice players and fans learning the game and trying to figure out things like who should back up which throws in which situations etc.

boomboomsubban 17 hours ago

It would be neat to recreate early radio, where a broadcaster would get a play-by-play over the wire and then announce it as if watching it, complete with sound effects. It was one of Ronald Reagan's early jobs.

  • nonethewiser 17 hours ago

    That is an interesting idea. And that sounds quite doable.

    Not sure about TOS but would be a natural fit as a twitch channel.

vunderba 17 hours ago

When I first read the description of this project I actually assumed that it was using ASCII in the terminal to recreate the current state of the game...

RankingMember 18 hours ago

> The obvious next step is to train a model to turn these detailed updates into realistic live-action video.

Wasn't obvious to me- sounds like you've got an idea that might be fun to pursue.

iancmceachern 16 hours ago

"Just because you can, doesn't mean you should"

- Everyone's favorite chaotician

samrus 17 hours ago

That video would be such slop. It wont be as fun as watching an actual pitch/hit.

Also the fun baseball stuff, the kind jomboy covers, wont ever be in the video because its not in the feed

intrikate 17 hours ago

Why would they shit a brick over people using data to ask a computer to generate videos of... a game they already captured video of?