Comment by creddit

I decided to install this and the updated iOS today to see how I felt about it.

My very initial impressions on MacOS:

(1) I like the look of Safari better and the Mail app compared to the prior designs. They both look really nice to me and the Mail app especially looks like a huge improvement in terms of design unification with some of the features like summaries and unsubscribe options that looked bolted on in the past now blending in seamlessly.

(2) I really, really don't like the new icons! Especially so on iOS.

(3) On iOS the app group/folders look terrible to me with the way they distort my wallpaper. Not a fan.

(4) A lot of people are complaining about transparent icons. It's not a valid complaint and is strong evidence whoever is saying that hasn't used the new OS as that is a choice you can make if you want. The default is not transparent.

(5) The increased radii in some places doesn't seem to have any meaningful impact to my information density. A simple comparison of Chrome (old styling) and Safari (with the liquid glass design) shows that Safari has a few pixels fewer in height search + tab bar as a concrete example.

(6) Messages app in MacOS looks like shit. I hate almost everything about it.

(7) Spotlight search has marked improvements! UI is nicer and functionality has expanded greatly (eg clipboard search).