Comment by LegionMammal978
Comment by LegionMammal978 10 hours ago
Of course they aren't magic, but people keep talking about them as if they're perfectly robust and ready-to-use for any problem within their domain. In reality, unless you have lots of experience in how to "use them correctly" (which is not something I think can be taught by rote), you'd be better off restricting their use to precisely the OR/verification problems they're already popular for.
Hence my statement about education. All tools must be used correctly in their proper domain, that is true. Don’t try to drive screws with a hammer. But I'm curious what problems you tried them on and found them wanting and what your alternative was? I actually find that custom solutions work better for simple problems and that solvers do a lot better when the problem complexity grows. You’re better off solving the Zebra puzzle and its ilk with brute force code, not a solver, for instance.