Comment by bluGill

Using a bad algorithm when a good algorithm that is known to exist is premature pessimization and should be avoided.

There is some debate about what premature optimization is, but I consider it about micro optimizations that often are doing things a modern compiler will do for you better than you can. All too often such attempts result in unreadable code that is slower because the optimizer would have done something different but now it cannot. Premature optimization is done without a profiler - if you have a profile of your code and can show a change really makes a difference then it isn't premature.

On the other hand job interviews imply time pressure. If someone isn't 100% sure how to implement the optimization algorithm without looking it up brute force is faster and should be chosen then. In the real world if I'm asked to do something I can spend days researching algorithms at times (though the vast majority of the time what I need is already in my language's standard library)