Comment by wqaatwt

Comment by wqaatwt a day ago

5 replies

> We tried that for 40 years. The result is drawers full of chargers.

Which is a fine? The industry eventually converged to just a handful of common standards on its own.

You can’t innovate without being able to experiment. Which is only possible if there are actual people using your product. Thinking that a committee of bureaucrats can replace that is silly.

saubeidl a day ago

A handful of common standards is useless.

One standard for chargers is the only acceptable outcome and it wouldn't have gotten there without regulation.

What need is there to experiment with chargers? Wire go in, power go through - it's really not that complicated, the only important thing is standardization.

  • wqaatwt a day ago

    > What need is there to experiment with chargers?

    That’s the point, I have no clue. But we might still be stuck with floppy drives with a mindset like that.

    Although as a physical connector usb-c is far from perfect. IMHO lighting seemed nicer in some ways.

    • saubeidl 21 hours ago

      > But we might still be stuck with floppy drives with a mindset like that.

      That seems like a false equivalency to me. It seems quite obvious that storage media have more potential for development than charging wires.

      Wire go in - power go through, is literally all they need to do and USB-C does that pretty well.

      • 3836293648 4 hours ago

        No, it's cable go in, power go through, *cable doesn't fall out* and usb-c does that terribly after a few months.

        I'm extremely pro standardisation, but the next revision needs to do a lot better.

  • qcnguy 9 hours ago

    MagSafe is a superior power connector in every way.