Comment by MrDunham

Comment by MrDunham 8 hours ago

1 reply

This is the correct answer. I like to go one step further than the root comment:

Nearly all of my "agents" are required to ask at least three clarifying questions before they're allowed to do anything (code, write a PRD, write an email newsletter, etc)

Force it to ask one at a time and it's event better, though not as step-function VS if it went off your initial ask.

I think the reason is exactly what you state @7thpower: it takes a lot of thinking to really provide enough context and direction to an LLM, especially (in my opinion) because they're so cheap and require no social capital cost (vs asking a colleague / employee—where if you have them work for a week just to throw away all their work it's a very non-zero cost).

iaw 6 hours ago

My routine is:

Prompt 1: <define task> Do not write any code yet. Ask any questions you need for clarification now.

Prompt 2: <answer questions> Do not write any code yet. What additional questions do you have?

Reiterate until questions become unimportant.