Comment by SwamyM

Comment by SwamyM 5 days ago

10 replies

View on Hacker News

> 2: When I sort my photos on a Pixel, I sort them in folders. The "camera" folder is where the unsorted photos are. When I sit in a bus or in a cafe, I go through it and sort the new photos into folders. This seems impossible on iPhones. Everything stays in the main folder forever. You can add photos to albums, but that does not remove them from the main folder. So there is no way to know which photos I have already sorted.

This along with iOS dumping pictures from WhatsApp, etc. into your main pictures folder is such a huge deal breaker for me. If I am backing up my pictures to a hard drive, there is no easy way to select just the pictures taken on my phone. Seems like such an oversight but I suspect it's a way to drive people to sign up for iCloud storage.

odo1242 5 days ago

> This along with iOS dumping pictures from WhatsApp, etc. into your main pictures folder is such a huge deal breaker for me.

This is WhatsApp's fault. "Settings > Chats > Save To Photos OFF" should fix it

Reply View 3 replies
  • ars 4 days ago

    That doesn't fix it, that just means I don't see WhatsApp photos.

    I want the two photos in different places.

    Reply View 2 replies
    • odo1242 a day ago

      How does Android fix that?

      Reply View 1 reply
      • ars 18 hours ago

        Android has directories (folders), and it doesn't pretend they don't exist.

        If you go to "Collections" -> "Photos on Device" it then shows separate folders "Camera", "WhatsApp Videos", "WhatsApp Photos", "Screenshots", etc, etc.

        Reply View 0 replies
antgiant 5 days ago

iOS 26 fixes this with an option to only show photos not in an album.

Additionally, if you are backing up photos to a hard drive you will be much better off using an app like PhotoSync. It has a one time payment and transfers direct to whatever you want with far less errors and more control than Apple’s terrible buggy disaster that is transferring photos by wire.

Reply View 1 reply
  • radicality 5 days ago

    It’s actually already available in iOS 18! On the main Photos page, click the little filtering icon and select something like “Not in any album”

    Reply View 0 replies
hammock 5 days ago

I can’t believe there isn’t a fix for this. I thought I was the only person with these problems. How have they persisted for so long?

Reply View 0 replies
frollogaston 5 days ago

The inability to sync albums as folders onto my Mac is my #1 complaint about iPhones. It's probably to sell iCloud.

Reply View 0 replies
nielsbot 5 days ago

Isn't that something WhatsApp is specifically doing tho? I haven't seen this behavior.

Reply View 1 reply