Comment by xphos

I disagree that consider the effects on supply and demand that taxes have is simplification or ignoring real economics is fallacy?

My only point was that its a supply issue not really a tax issue. Houses already have tax on them called property tax its small yes but the reason investors are buying houses is not because the tax is small but because the demand for them is extremely high and the supply is very low. Adding a tax does not in any way fix the demand imbalance. This is why things like price controls only create shortages the problem is that its impossible to build houses because of nimbism.

A Tax doesn't make more houses exist even without investors there isn't enough houses because of local zoning and protesting prevents cheap housing from entering the market. A Tax that does not solve this problem still means that there are to many people buying / renting chasing to few houses.