jonathanlydall a day ago

Most of the culture novels are around a Special Circumstances situation. The minds and other science fiction elements are largely (albeit quite richly detailed) backdrop to a human protagonist’s actions.

Despite the utopian culture, there are still very messy and complicated situations.

  • [removed] 21 hours ago
    [deleted]
dontlaugh a day ago

That’s also about people. And communism.

Only some of the people in the series are space ships.

  • mr_toad 13 hours ago

    > And communism

    By a literal definition communism means the collective ownership of the means of production.

    In the Culture the means of production own themselves, and they don’t seem to answer to anyone unless it suits them.

    • dontlaugh 12 hours ago

      Socialism is the transition stage where collective ownership of the means of production, where the working class gains state power from the capitalist class.

      Communism is a later stage of such abundance that money, classes and state power become redundant and are abolished.

      The Culture is an imagining of the latter, where many means of production become people. They thus become workers that can labour for each other if they collectively decide to.

      • mr_toad an hour ago

        My reading of the Culture novels is that few people produce anything at all, or do any work or labour, and nearly every is produced by the ships, orbitals, and the Minds that control them. It’s not clear who exactly decides what gets produced, but decision making seems to be largely controlled by the Minds.

        • dontlaugh an hour ago

          The Minds are people too. Production happens individually at the small scale and based on collective decisions at the large scale. The Minds sway public opinion, but ultimately the public at large makes large decisions like the Idiran war.