Comment by josephg
You’re thinking about it from the perspective of a site operator. Yes, individual websites could do that. But not all websites would use such a redirect.
But think about it from the perspective of a web browser or curl. You can’t rely on all web servers having such a redirect for their URLs. Web browsers would need to support old versions of TLS to make old URLs work. They’d need to support old versions of tls indefinitely so as to not break old URLs.
Using an old version of tls isn’t like using an old version of the C compiler. Old versions of tls have well documented problems with security implications. That’s why we made new versions. Maintaining lots of versions of TLS multiplies the security surface area for bugs, and makes you vulnerable to downgrade attacks.
Like, you're right that some, perhaps many, sites would continue using https, just like in the current situation, many sites continue supporting http (instead of just setting up a redirect)
No site needs to do this though, and I can't recall seeing a site with sensitive user info that supports http in recent years. And in the current situation, many sites are still supporting old versions of https (SSL2). A protocol name upgrade would give you more certainty that you're connecting over a secure connection, and perhaps a better indication if you've accidentally used a less-secure connection than intended.
I mean actually your exact argument could be made about http vs https, that http+SSL should have become the default (without changing the protocol name of http://), and by changing the protocol name it made it so that some websites still accept http. I guess in practice there's a slight difference since http->https involved a default port change and ssl2 -> tls did not, so in the former case the name change was important to let clients know to use a different default port; but ignoring that, the same argument could be made, and I would have disagreed with it there too.
Specifying the protocol... in the protocol portion of the URL... can be useful for users.