Comment by kimixa

Comment by kimixa 3 days ago

2 replies

Don't forget how much of a "high-performance" implementation is due to the physical implementation, a lot of engineering effort is put into that post-HDL. And much below HDL is hard to share, as it relies too much on (closed) fab IP libraries and PDK specifics. And then the verification of that result.

Which might discourage an Open Source hardware project with shared ownership as large as a high performance implementation would require - as each cooperating company would end up using rather different products anyway.

I fear it'll become just an "Dump Over The Wall An Old Snapshot" of a few different companies work at best, rather than true cooperation.

zozbot234 3 days ago

There are open source PDK and IP libraries, though only for nodes far from the leading edge. OTOH, trailing-edge nodes are also the most viable overall for cheaper and smaller-scale fabrication.

adgjlsfhk1 3 days ago

I don't think open source will be getting anywhere near leading edge in the near future, but I feel like a really good n12 or n7 chip might be possible. That would be enough to get to ~Zen1 levels of performance (or maybe a bit higher since we know Zen1 had some fairly avoidable mistakes)