Comment by aurareturn

Comment by aurareturn 9 hours ago

4 replies

  But where did the Sun got it's low entropy photons to start with? From gravity, empty uniform space has low entropy, which got "scooped up" as the Sun formed.
From the Big Bang originally. We don’t know what caused the Big Bang.
gavinray 8 hours ago

The end of the previous Big Bang, a-la Big Bounce ;^)

"It's turtles all the way down."

  • jerf 4 hours ago

    One of the major challenges with "Big Bounce" that media coverage of it tends to overlook is that it is not entirely clear how the previous universe, which is presumably high entropy if it's supposed to be like ours, becomes the low entropy feedstock for the next universe. There's still a "And Here There Be Magic" step there.

    I'm not saying there's no solution; indeed, this is the sort of thing where the problem is that the profusion of proposed solutions is exactly the thing that shows there's a problem there. I think people tend to intuitively think that "lots and lots of possible solutions" is somehow better than "no solutions at all" but they're actually nearly the same thing.

  • layer8 2 hours ago

    You’d have to explain how the steadily increasing entropy in our universe would revert to a low-entropy state again.