Comment by ricardobeat
Comment by ricardobeat a day ago
> Badly signing a recent pop song in public also qualifies as copyright infringement
For commercial purposes only. If someone sells a recreation of the Harry Potter book, it’s illegal regardless whether it was by memory, directly copying the book, or using an LLM. It’s the act of broadcasting it that’s infringing on copyright, not the content itself.
There’s a bunch of nuance here.
But just for clarification, selling a recreation isn’t required for copyright infringement. The copying itself can be problematic so you can’t defend yourself by saying you haven’t yet sold any of the 10,000 copies you just printed. There are some exceptions that allow you to make copies for specific purposes, skip protection on a portable CD player for example, but that doesn’t apply to the 10k copies situation.