Comment by energy123

Comment by energy123 6 months ago

2 replies

I'm on the optimistic side with how useful LLMs are, but I have to agree. You cultivate the instinct for how to steer the models and reduce hallucinations, but you're not building articulable knowledge or engaging in challenging thinking. It's more learning muscle-memory reactions to certain forms of LLM output that lean you towards trusting the output more, trying another prompting strategy, clearing context or not, and so on.

To the extent we can call it skill, it's probably going to be made redundant in a few years as the models get better. It gives me a kind of listlessness that assembly line workers would feel.

namaria 6 months ago

Maybe, much like we invented gyms to exercise after civilization made most physical labor redundant (at least in developed countries), we will see a rise of 'creative writing gyms' of some sort in the future.

  • deinonychus 6 months ago

    I like this outlook a lot. I suppose I've met a lot of people that do creative writing recreationally and also socially in clubs, writing not just poetry but also things like adventures for roleplaying games like D&D.

    I wonder what the commercialized form of a "gym but for your brain" would look like and if it would take off and if it would be more structured than... uh... schools? Wait, wouldn't this just be like a college except the students are there because they want to be, and not for vocational reasons?