Comment by timschmidt

Comment by timschmidt 20 hours ago

5 replies

> Do you know every common programing language? The LLM does, plus it can code in FRACTRAN, Brainfuck, Binary lambda calculus, and a dozen other obscure languages.

Not only this, but they're surprisingly talented at reading compiled binaries in a dozen different machine and bytecodes. I have seen one one-shot an applet rewrite from compiled java bytecode to modern javascript.

catigula 11 hours ago

And herein lies the fundamental power of the LLM and why it can even solve "impressive" problems: it is able to navigate a space that humans can't trivially - massive amounts of information and ability to parse through walls of simple logic/text.

LLMs are at their best when the context capacity of the human is stretched and the task doesn't really take any reasoning but requires an extraction of some basic, common pattern.

  • dylan604 11 hours ago

    > it is able to navigate a space that humans can't trivially - massive amounts of information and ability to parse through walls of simple logic/text.

    That’s the very reason we built computers. If an LLM did not also meet this definition, there would be no point of it existing

    • catigula 11 hours ago

      You're not the first person to suggest that LLMs have no reason to exist.

anthk 18 hours ago

Binwalk, Unicorn... as if it that was advanced wizardry. Unix systems have file(1) since forever and binutils from and to every arch.

  • Energiekomin 12 hours ago

    Yes it is and you compare apples with pineapples.

    file can't program in brainfuck while doing basic binary analysis.

    Binwalk and Unicorn can't do that either. And they can't write to you in multiply natural languages either