avidiax a day ago

I'm using the Monoprice multiviewer. It negotiates HDCP without a display attached. Other than being a bit big and expensive, and being unable to strip HDCP, it's a good solution.

I found the same device in generic packaging on AliExpress, but haven't had the chance to order that version, yet.

There are lots of professional SDI converters and such, but they are either $3k+ or "call for price".

kevin_b_er 21 hours ago

That was written by you?

I don't agree with this section:

> The HDCP converter simply announces itself as a final video endpoint… yet still repeats the content to its output port. Without a very expensive HDMI protocol analyzer, we can’t check if the source is tagging the content as type 0 or type 1, but there is no reason now to think that it’s not type 1.

There's no magic in the HDMI protocol that says type 1 vs type 0. Its just another HDCP message over DDC, but it is only sent to repeaters. In this case, since the HDCP Repeater is lying about not being a repeater, it isn't getting sent the StreamID Type information.

Sporktacular 20 hours ago

Great teardown. Can these things remove HDCP altogether? It seems like if it can report that the sink is HDCP2.x then it can do so even if it has no compliance at all right? So that would mean it streams an encrypted stream to something that needs to then still do the decryption? These devices seem like they'd be underpowered to do that in real time at 18 Gb/s.

  • tverbeure 16 hours ago

    I assume the silicon can do it, but it’s not exposed to the user, because that would almost certainly be a license violation.