SumatraPDF is outstanding software. But I'm actually surprised to hear that it seems to be written in C++ ... I dunno, kind of like "by default?" And a blog post hand rolling callback functions using structs and a bunch of pointers seems to double down on: are you sure this language is getting you where you want to go?
I didn't know how to correctly package my comment as not criticizing, and that's half of why I opened with "is outstanding software." I genuinely believe that, I'm deeply grateful for you releasing SumatraPDF into the world, and it makes my life better. Truly, I am thankful
I hear you about "back in my day," but since as best I can tell it's just your project (that is, not a whole team of 50 engineers who have to collaborate on the codebase) so you are the audience being done a disservice by continuing to battle a language that hates you
As for the interop, yes, since the 70s any language that can't call into a C library is probably DoA but that list isn't the empty set, as you pointed out with the ones you've actually considered. I'd even suspect if you tried Golang it may even bring SumatraPDF to other platforms which would be another huge benefit to your users
Don't worry about being nice, 15 years doing open source develops a thick skin.
But you didn't respond: which language should I use?
Go didn't exist when I started SumatraPDF.
And while I write pretty much everything else in Go and love the productivity, it wouldn't be a good fit.
A big reason people like Sumatra is that it's fast and small. 10 MB (of which majority are fonts embedded in the binary) and not 100MB+ of other apps.
Go's "hello world" is 10 MB.
Plus abysmal (on Windows) interop with C / C++ code.
And the reason SumatraPDF is unportable to mac / linux is not the language but the fact that I use all the Windows API I can for the UI.
Any cross-platform UI solution pretty much require using tens of megabytes of someone else's reimplementation of all the UI widgets (Qt, GTK, Flutter) or re-implementing a smaller subset of UI using less code.
I would have recommended Go but if it increases file size, please don't. Anyways, it is very fast and quick so keep it the way it is. I can't find a reason to change it.
It can even do comments. But I would like to see more comment tools, especially measurement tools.
And since you are using Windows, do you think it would be worthwhile to add Windows OCR?
being done a disservice by continuing to battle a language that hates you
I think you should learn basic modern C++ before making judgements like this.
While you are upset about it the rest of the world is just using basic data structures, looping through them, never dealing with garbage collection and enjoying fast and light software that can run on any hardware.
A lot of people could get by with $100 computers if all software was written like sumatraPDF.
As opposed to?
Today, if I was starting from scratch, I would try zig or odin or maybe even Go.
But SumatraPDF started 15 years. There was nothing but C++. And a much different C++ that C++ of today.
Plus, while my own code is over 100k lines, external C / C++ libraries are multiple of that so (easy) integration with C / C++ code is a must.